Hmm. I seem to recall the Carra Henchoz Hyypia Babbel backline being pretty solid, and we didn't really expect him to create did we? Be interesting to see modern stats for that period
Not once did they concede less than 30 goals in the league. For all of Alexander-Arnold's weaknesses, he became a regular in a side that first made a CL-final, the season after won it, got 97 points and conceded 22 goals in the league, while setting a new record for assists for a fullback. I know which player I'd rather have in my team.
It's absurd to expect someone as influential to our attack to be Baresi in defence as well, he's probably the least protected player in our team as Salah is playing as a striker on his side, and yet he's more than decent enough and part of an excellent defence.