I think with Nunez there's just no consistency. He jumps wildly between elite and looking like a donkey, so I can understand how both sides of the debate can get entrenched.
For me, I want him replaced. Even knowing full well he'll have a season where everything falls right for him and he'll score 25-30 in the league.
I can't stand the offsides, the bad touches, or the poor passes that break down our attack constantly. I don't think it's a good plan to rely on lady luck and hold out for the season it call goes right.
He has played in 62 PL games for Liverpool, and only scored in 16 of those. It's not consistent enough.
Yes you can talk minutes, but the reality is the best players command those minutes. If Nunez was consistent enough he'd be on the pitch.