I think a lot of people think this.
But I’m not sure what Klopp thinks. Did he view Caicedo as a pure 6 or more of a hybrid 6/8?
Was the switch to Gravenberch a complete change in strategy after missing out on Caicedo or the next option on the list for a certain type of midfielder (in terms of potential skill set)?
It’s hard to know the above with any certainty and therefore I’m not sure if we’ve landed on this pool of midfielders by design (I.e we wanted range of multi functional midfielders from mid summer) or due to circumstance and compromise.
It’s a really interesting conversation. My thesis would be that he saw Caicedo as the 6 in our formation, that is the deepest lying midfielder who would progress the play along with Trent, stay behind the ball and, most importantly in terms of his specific skill set, be a supreme athlete capable of getting round the pitch and so putting out fires. When you compare Caicedo’s offensive output (minimal) with our other midfielders (aside from Endo) it’s pretty clear he wasn’t going to play as an 8 in the new system which sees the 8s be a lot more progressive than they used to be. Caicedo could certainly have played the Henderson role in the old 433 (covering for Trent) but even if we’d gone back to that he’d have also been the most obvious 6 in the old 433.
Re Gravenberch - I think the club rates him very highly and has wanted him for ages. Once Thiago leaves there’ll clearly be room for another 8 in the squad and so we took advantage of his availability even though it leaves the group a little unbalanced at the moment. Although if Mac is going to play as a 6 it’s fine because you have Grav, Szoboslai, Jones and Elliot for the 8 roles. So bringing him in was more about wanting him than saying anything about a wider strategy or a decision to move away from having a proper DM in the team. I think the king standing interest is reasonably good evidence of this.
I’m reasonably confident (although of course it’s guess work) that if we’d gotten Caicedo we wouldn’t have got Endo but we’d still have gotten Gravenberch, assuming the finances worked. And that would have let us with a very balanced group of players.
DM: Caicedo, Bacjetic, Thiago
8: Mac, Szoboslai, Jones, Grav, Elliot.
Thiago goes at the end of the season and let the youngsters battle it out for playing time and the strongest survive. One or two of them probably end up leaving in a year or two because they don’t get the game time.