Some interesting line-ups. It would be great if we could actually see the drafter's ideas in action. In match-ups you could have both guys post their plays tuned toward that opponent, and we could judge the veracity, more info to vote. Say you play Ronaldo on the wing and your opponent runs a specific play to exploit the lack of protection the fullback on that side will be getting, that could earn my vote.
It's how football works in real life. It seems you guys have a long standing drafting community but ultimately you just post 11 names up on a static board... A lot of wasted potential there, room to build things. The game is in how the players work together.