I didn't see anything wrong with Carroll's performance. I don't know where that's coming from.
I'm sure if you went back and tracked the match film, you'd find that he dominated in the air. Took his goal well (and it was a goal, no reason for it to be disallowed), and generally was excellent in his link-up play.
I realize, that on FIFA, when you've got Zlatan up top, it's easy enough to hold up every ball and dribble through the defence for a goal, but that's not reality.