The "flaws" since he joined from people on here are;
* cant beat his man
* lacks skill to take people on
* no pace
* doesnt cut inside
* cuts inside far too much (weird)
* doesn't hug the line
* just tracks up the line up and down.
* cant shoot
* cant cross
* loses possesion
most of them are not true and i am sure you know that but you're trying to make some point to the others.
i think he has progressed well this season and improved parts of his game that looked well crappy in the beginning of this season. the things i would like him to improve are:
(1) his positioning in the last third of the pitch so that he can get himself into goal scoring positions
(2) keep the flow of the game going. this is one of the main problems i've had with him this season. many a time he has held on to the ball 5 to 10 second more than he has had to. he cuts inside and then outside and then inside by which time the players around him who were making runs have already been closed down.
(3) burst of pace while one on one. to be fair, he has shown he is capable of that once or twice this season, but i want him to be more consistent.
(1) and (2) can come with confidence and management from rafa. (3) i am still doubtful of because considering he is a "traditional winger" who likes to hug the byeline, pace has never been his main attribute. and unfortunately, in the system that rafa plays, pace is a huge, huge aspect for our success.
although i like pennant and believe he has the attributes to be a success at the club in his own way, i fear there'll be new wingers coming in who will make pennant a squad player.