To help me answer if I'm happy, I've dug up a post I made way back on May 18th in the 1st transfer shitchat thread, and added some comments in bold and strikethroughs to reflect what actually happened:
How I see the situation, in a slightly Football Manager-esque way
Outgoing: ~£35-45m £8m + £75m for Suarez. I was apparently a bit overoptimistic with my estimates, but if Agger had gone for market value and players like Assaidi had gone too I wouldn't have been far off.
Reina £5m £2m to Bayern
Jones £1-2m
Agger £10-12m £3m to Brondby
Coates £2-3m Loaned to Sunderland
Kelly/Toure £3m £1.5+
Aspas £4-5m Loaned to Sevilla with option to buy (I think)
Assaidi £5m Loaned to Stoke for £1m
Lucas £10m
Connor Coady- £3m 500k+
Robinson - £2m £1m
Moses £0
Cissokho £0
Luis Suarez £75m
Loan out:
Luis Alberto - La Liga or lower PL, similar to Suso and Ilori this year - Loaned to Malaga in La Liga
Andre Wisdom - Derby again if they get promoted? Would be good RB cover for us otherwise Loaned to West Brom
Joao Teixeira - Southampton, Swansea, or another footballing team in the PL Loaned to Brighton
Jack Robinson - Blackpool this year, so maybe lower PL or upper Championship next season Sold to QPR for £1m
Brad Smith - Championship Loaned to Swindon in League 1
McLaughlin - Was at relegated Barnsley this season in the Championship, so maybe a better Championship side would suit him.Still at LFC, but a loan is still possible
Jordan Ibe - Loaned to Derby
Ilori - Loaned to Bordeaux
Incoming: ~£90m approx. £116.5m
GK - £5mValdes to come in October?... Also signed Vigouroux for the youth team on a free
CB- Caulker £7m Lovren £20m
RB- Manquillo on loan from Atletico, and Stewart for youth team on a free
LB - Rodriguez £20m Moreno £12m
CM - Kovacic? £15m Emre Can £10m
AM - Lallana £22m £23m
LW/ST - Griezmann £25m Markovic £20m, Balotelli £16m, and Lambert £4m. Also Origi £9.8m.
Net spend: £90m minus ~£35m outgoings = around £50-55. £116.5 - £83m = £33.5m
Mignolet
GK
Johnson Caulker Sakho Rogriguez
Flanagan Skrtel Ilori Enrique
Kelly/Toure
Gerrard
CM (Kovacic?)
Rossiter
Henderson Lallana
Coutinho Allen
Suso
Sterling Griezmann
Ibe Borini
Suarez
Sturridge
There's going to be plenty of turnover in the squad, with at least 2-3 top quality players coming in. As the numbers above show it isn't unreasonable to expect that we'd be able to pull off up to three £20m signings too by selling off fringe players and players like Agger and Lucas (who are the only two who really got in our side with any regularity this season of that bunch btw, but even they are 2nd choice now). Most of my estimates for player sales are on the prudent side as well, so there is potential for even more funds to be raised with good business to offset the incoming players' transfer fees.
Interestingly, I got most of my transfer outgoings right, and was reasonably close in guessing the positions we'd target even if the names were completely off. Drawing out the squad options (in 433 format for consistency) and comparing it to the prediction I made above that I would have been happy with at the start of the summer, and all of our positions of need/positions requiring upgrades have been filled (apart from GK).
Mignolet
Jones
Manquillo Lovren Sakho Moreno
Johnson Skrtel Toure Enrique
Flanagan
Gerrard
Lucas
Rossiter
Henderson Lallana
Coutinho Allen
Can
Sterling Markovic
Suso Borini
Sturridge
Balotelli
Lambert
(Origi)
Positives:- Bringing in a very good player for every single position we were looking to fill, apart from maybe the backup goalkeeper slot.
- Selling players on high wages like Reina and Agger
- Finding great loan destinations for most of our loanable players. This is a massive plus imo. WBA, Derby, Brighton, Bordeaux, Malaga, Sevilla, Sunderland, etc are good clubs and the right levels for each of our loanees this season.
- Managed to get rid of most of our dead-wood, apart from arguably Borini.
- Net spend of only £33.5m means that there's surely big potential to sign someone in January if needed, or space to reward players like Sterling, Coutinho, and Sturridge with better deals.
Negatives:- Selling the 3rd best player in the world.
- Unable to sell Aspas, Borini, and Assaidi.
- Selling Agger for way under his market value (even if it was for sentimental reasons).
- Only raising £8m through sales in total other than the Suarez deal
- Not bringing in a GK to compete with Mignolet.
- Haven't sorted out Suso's long term situation. Ideally he would have been extended and sent on loan.
All in all, I'd say its been an incredibly smooth and prudent window for the club.
- The incoming transfer business worked like clock-work, with players coming in at regular intervals during the summer, indicating that the committee were really efficient with their business rather than letting things drift on until late in the window. Getting players in early also allowed most of them to have a full preseason with Brendan.
- The Suarez sale was dealt with quickly, allowing the committee to get on with other business (instead of doing a Spurs and allowing the story to be a distraction in the media, as well as holding up other transfers).
- All other sales were completed in August after Brendan had a chance to assess all players in preseason, and loans were also sorted out in a timely fashion near the end of the deadline.
Its hard to argue against the fact that this has been a wonderful transfer window for the club, and although one or two things could have gone better, overall I think we can all say that we are exhilarated with the state of the squad after this summer's business.
Looking forwards, its very easy to see what the plans for the coming two windows will be as well to keep shaping the squad.
- Toure and Johnson will be allowed to run-down their contracts.
- The remaining 27-30 year olds on high salaries (Lucas, Enrique, and Skrtel) will be sold and replaced with younger options such as Ilori, Smith, Rossiter, or new purchases.
- Borini will be sold, and Origi will take his place in the squad, and eventually Lambert's role as the 3rd striker.
- Gerrard will see his game time gradually diminish. We should be in the market for a top deep-playmaker or DM next summer as a long-term replacement (unless Can is seen as that player already). That will probably be our biggest "splash" or the summer I reckon, along with moves for 2-3 defenders to replace the aforementioned players in the squad.
Any way you look at it our future is looking immensely promising, and that's without even mentioning how much talent there is coming through the youth teams, such as Conor Randall, Harry Wilson, Jack Dunn, Philips, Rossiter, etc