I was looking on his profile over there and their trophies (badges they get for certain number of posts/likes) are all named after memorable Everton highlights such as -
10
May 17, 2014
1931-32 League Title
Your content has been liked 250 times.
10
Feb 19, 2014
1927-28 League Title
Your messages have been 'Liked' 25 times! You've won the 1927-28 League Title. Everton trophies are awarded dependent on your forum activity. The more you collect, the higher 'Player Valuation' assigned to your member account.
10
Feb 15, 2014
1930-31 Division Two League Title
You've won the 1930-31 Division Two League Title for posting 200 messages! Everton trophies are awarded dependent on your forum activity. The more you collect, the higher 'Player Valuation' assigned to your member account.
10
Feb 15, 2014
1914-15 League Title
You've won the 1914-15 League Title for posting 100 messages! Everton trophies are awarded dependent on your forum activity. The more you collect, the higher 'Player Valuation' assigned to your member account.
10
Feb 15, 2014
1906 FA Cup
You've won the 1906 FA Cup for posting 30 messages! Everton trophies are awarded dependent on your forum activity. The more you collect, the higher 'Player Valuation' assigned to your member account.
10
Feb 15, 2014
1890-91 League Title
Post a message somewhere on the site to receive Everton's first ever trophy! Everton trophies are awarded dependent on your forum activity. The more you collect, the higher 'Player Valuation' assigned to your member account.