Prof you have the whole history of soccer ball to pick categories from so why are you giving me a category to pick Newcastle players from the late 90's from?.
There are 12 rounds with a maximum of 22 players added each round. That's just over 250 players, between 16 of you. That works out at about 16 players each. If they were all top class, it would take the value out of some of the players and make trading less likely.
I want to create an active transfer market. That's achieved by limiting supply.
There have been some belting matches in the lower leagues.