Judging based on a BETA version of PES and without playing FIFA at all? Lol
If im honest mate and im not talking about people in here, but just those Pro evo fanboys across the web, its ok but its certainly not worth the hype and reading about across the web on Evo Web and WENB. I listened to the podkast with that Adam lad and Suff yesterday and they were banging on about how this is the complete title and bears no resemblance to the demo.
But then they said that last year too. In their haste to keep in with Konami, they've praised previous years games too much when they were just average and so its a case of the boy who cried wolf.
What astounds me and admitedlly really baffles is that people give fifa a right kicking on the likes of WENB, Fifa soccer blog and Evo web, for all the annoyances that i can see in this pro evo.
Ball watching defenders from a chipped through pass? Check. EA was hammered for that as i recall. A gamebreaker they said in Fifa 10. Well ive seen it several times in this demo. You do it, chip a forward ball and your striker will get to it 8/10 times.
You cant dribble and beat man on fifa they say. You cant dribble and beat a man on this demo! You get tackled nearly every time even with someone like Nani or Neymar. And the reason why is you cant out run a defender even if you have a fast player! I can actually do it on fifa and in fact with Suarez have squeezed my way through defenders and megged them.
The passing on fifa is crap was another. Manual passing has no individuality. Well the passing on this is badly scripted. I can press full power on pass to a man five yards away and it goes there, it doesnt go past him. Turning assisted passing off and its still the same. THe a.i assisted curl is there too, just like fifa.
You cant score the same variety of goals that you can in pes. Again another fallicy. Whack it on manual shooting, learn it and start banging them in with loads of variety, and importantly missing easy chances too. Thats the way it should be. For me with pes its pot luck. I shoot the same way twice with the same player and it can fly straight in, or fly over the bar. I have no control over it.
And thats some of the stupid stuff that gets spouted.
This is a solid game, but still with deep flaws. Ill give the second demo a shot and make my judgement. In my opinion though i dont think it will be all that dissimilar to what we have now.