I voted for the new stadium. My heart says it would be lovely to stay at Anfield, but think the advantages of the new stadium are too great to turn down.
For a kick off half the leg work has been done in terms of planning permission etc, the design is there (if we dont mind going with the H&G design), there is Council approval and even some cash available in terms of grants etc too I think.
Staying at Anfield we would have to start from scratch, pay for feasibility studes, architect designs, consultations with residents and council etc which would delay things for quite a while, we would lose capacity initially while work is going on to extend etc which also has a financial aspect. Whether we would be able to improve things like car parking and transport to and from is also doubtful.
So, while I love Anfield, I just think the new stadium would be right for us in the long term view.