Brentie..a couple of fantastic posts.
Regarding Mignolet.
One has to step back to when we bought him. Pepe wanted out. I'd suggest Brendan tried to keep him but Pepe had made up his mind. Sometimes players need a new challenge and just want a new club.
So we're left with an empty basket to fill.
The transfer committee will have, like now, a list of names. I guess some think you just choose someone and they come like a video game. You just go get who you want.
As you've mentioned Mignolet isn't ideal to a Rodgers way of playing 11 not 10. So why choose Simon?
The committee and Rodgers will have all the stats before them. Will have the scouting reports noting strengths and weaknesses. So Brendan will prioritize based on all the information at his disposal which, in this case, keeper to go after. At this point then you involve the selling club, agents, and the player. Whether Mignolet was first choice or not, he was on the list. And needs were a must. So Simon became the one who's club would negotiate, agent and player could come to an agreement.
Any youtube compilation will show a players strengths. Posters go looking for these whenever we are linked to any player. But scouting is where you get real information. Not just on positional strengths and weaknesses but attitude and demeanor. Abilities to be a team player. All the intangibles. Mentality if you like.
As I mentioned in this thread, maybe Rodgers and the committee weren't happy with some of the scouts and their reports. That's why some have been let go. So changes HAVE been made. Maybe Mognolets scouting was one of the reasons.
And for those asking the question: Would you trust Rodgers and the committee with money in January?
FSG have shown they will back those in charge. Not just in football but baseball as well. They more than anyone understand the process of transfer dealings. So come January, if there are deals to be made, can be made, then we'll get in a new player or two.