It's quite interesting the backlash over that sugar sugar song. I think it's an extreme example that sums up much of the problem at Anfield. As others have pointed out, if it was started by a scouser on the coach to an away then everyone would probably be singing it. Let's face it, it's just a better version of oh mane mane and that caught on fine.
We've got this whole day tripper debate that is a legitimate one but I really think it has lead to an extremely uptight reaction from many of the locals. As recently as maybe 2006/2007 the Kop was awash with scarves for YNWA and was a sea of red. Even for the big games now it's distinctly colourless because scarves and replica shirts are whopper/wool behaviour. We haven't had any decent songs since the Suarez/Maxi era (and even the suarez one was nicked from celtic) and have had an awful lack of player chants for years and i'm sure part of the reason for that is the sneering attitude to new songs and a fear of being labelled a whopper by the north face clad fellas.
There's plenty of reasons for the atmosphere being poor over recent years but I genuinely feel it's one of the contributing factors. Liverpool has a culture that sets it above every other team in the country and rightly gained a reputation for that that people want to defend. But we also had a reputation for having the best and most diverse songbook, right now all we've got is FOAR a million times, poetry in motion and 200 lads testing if the rest know the words to poor scouser tommy. If a new song gets the crowd noise up then it can only be a good thing.
Anyway, all that aside, it sounded magnificent yesterday anyway. Not so much the songs but you could see all four sides of the ground getting into it, people leaning over the advertising boards dishing out abuse, that proper snarling anfield atmosphere that makes it one of the most intimadating places in world football on its day. How many points a season would that be worth if we could do it every week?