I'm sure each and every one of them plus another dozen would be closer to 1st team football at Blackpool than they are at Liverpool, goes without saying I'd say. Whether it would be the best thing for them in the long run is another matter.
Ince isn't closer to first team football with Blackpool, since 2011, he's played
77 times for them, thats 77 games against fully developed men, in what is acknowledged as a physical and fast league. That has to push a player on and test whether they can make the required amount of progress. Meanwhile Coady, Sama and Adorjan (and others in our U21's) have been big fish in a far littler U21 pond where time on the ball is endless and players far less physical. I'm arguing that they would have all progressed far faster had they done what Ince did..........get out and get some genuine league experience.
No-one will know how how it will pan out in the long run, but looking at just one case.....Lukaku, Chelsea rated him highy, but knew he wouldn't get the game time if he stayed with them, so they leant him to WBA where he improved massively. Of course he could have stayed playing at U21 level, but what would he have learned?? He's actually 3 months younger than Coady.
The point I'm making isn't to knock Coady or any other u21 player on our books, it's to try and show that players need games to develop, and these guys are at a crucial age. if they dont get significant game time soon it's going to be too late for most of them.
Of our current first team, in the season they turned 21, (the season upcoming for Coady et al) they played the following number of times for their league club. Now we can dismiss the quality of some of these teams, but 7 of the 10 were playing regularly in the EPL.
Not a single player in our first team was in the U21's/Ressies age 20 to 21. they were all getting significant first team action. And thats the most important point, do we think any out of Coady, Adorjan, Sama (to name a few) will be?? Not in my opinion they won't, they aren't yet ready. It doesn't mean they can't make it, but the odds are stacking against them based on our first team from the second half of last season.
Glen Johnson, (1984) Age 20 season 2004/2005 - 17 league apps for Chelsea
Jamie Carragher (1978) Age 20 season 1998/1999 - 34 league apps for Liverpool
Daniel Agger (1984) Age 20 Season 2004/2005, - 26 league apps for Brondby
Jose Enrique (1986) Age 20 season 2006/2007 - 14 league apps for Celta Vigo
Joe Allen (1990) Age 20 season 2010/2011 - 43 league apps for Swansea City
Jordan Henderson (1990) Age 20 season 2010/2011 - 37 league apps for Sunderland
Lucas Leiva (1987) Age 20, season 2007/2008 - 18 league apps for Liverpool
Steven Gerrard (1980) Age 20, season 2000/2001 - 33 league apps for Liverpool
Stewart Downing (1984) age 20, season 2004/2005 - 35 league apps for Middlesbrough
Daniel Sturridge (1989) age 20 season 2009/10 - 13 league apps for Chelsea
Luis Suarez (1987) age 20 season 2007/2008 - 33 apps for Ajax
Philiipe Coutinho (1992) age 20 season 2012/2013 - 10 apps for Inter, 13 for Liverpool
(all stats from Soccerway)