I have to do it from the time I've been following the Reds, so 1994 onwards (I know some are going to be really scraping the barrel)
1. Dudek
2. Jones
3. Finnan
4. Hyypia
5. Agger
6. Babbel
7. Suarez
8. Gerrard
9. Torres
10. Barnes
11. Fowler (not his finest form but it gets him in)
12. Aurelio
13. Murphy
14. Alonso
15. Berger
16. Hamann
17. McManaman
18. Owen
19. Babel (purely for scoring against the Mancs)
20. Mascherano
21. McAllister (tough on Lucas but Gary Mac was sublime)
22. Sissoko
23. Carragher
24. Allen??
25. Reina
It gets ridiculous after that
Edit: actually for a bit of Friday fun if I separated that out into a squad it'd work quite well
GK; Reina, Dudek
FB; Finnan, Jones, Babbel, Aurelio
CB; Hyypia, Agger, Carragher,
CM; Alonso, Mascherano, Gerrard, Hamman, McAllister, Allen, Sissoko
AM/WG: McManaman, Barnes, Murphy, Berger, Babel
CF; Torres, Fowler, Owen, Suarez
and starting XI
Reina
Jones Hyypia Carragher Aurelio
Mascherano Alonso
Gerrard
Suarez Barnes
Fowler
Dudek, Agger, Finnan, Hamann, McAllister, McManaman, Torres