his comment seemed clear enough, well-rounded implying a similar skillset rather than saying he was as good as Firmino.
I know what he was implying. Being near any of the skillsets that Firmino currently has is over the top. He's a young lad, he's got loads to do to prove himself.
Then maybe it's you're comprehension skills.
See above.
If I said two years ago that TAA was a more well
Rounded footballer than Clyne you would say the same thing, but it's the truth even at youth level TAA was showing skills and capable of doing things Clyne could only dream of, at the same time as a player he wasn't close to being better than an England international and one pf the best Rbs in the league, but Clyne couldn't take a free kick like TAA, he couldn't pass like TAA or cross the ball like him even when Trent Arnold was 16, this doesn't mean saying all that I would play a 16 yet old TAA over Clyne as there are other important aspect to football and being a footballplayer than solely technical ability, which for most footballers only see them make marginal improvements from that age onwards anyways.
We're not talking about Trent nor Clyne here. To be quite frank with you I am not arsed what you would have said about Trent from two years ago. I am specifically talking about where Brewster is at the moment in comparison to Roberto Firmino who is one of our most important players.
Now use than example and apply same to what I said, Brewster is nearly as well rounded as Firmino because as a young striker he can do most things with the ball at his feet, for England u17's he played as a sort of poacher surrounded by creative marvels, for us he's played as a winger and a number 9 more involved in the build up, he can dovetail between roles so seamlessly because not only is he a well rounded footballer but an intelligent one also, (this was a point made by Babuyugu at the time as well)y et saying that there's players at a higher level who can do less on paper but are better strikers than the young lad is right now, and there are technical maestros playing in league 1 who couldn't put some premiership footballers to shame on a pure technical basis.
Again I am not arsed about Trent and Clyne and the differences between them, or what one could do and couldn't do. We're talking about Brewster and Firmino. You asked specifically what was over the top, I gave you a specific answer. I am not arsed about what some can do in league 1 or what Babuyugu said [with all due respect to him] and what Premiership footballers can or can't do.
The discussion at hand is how close is Brewster to Firmino. You asked what was the over the top. I told you. He isn't near Firmino in any skillset or ability. Keyword being near. I didn't say he wasn't good or that he didn't have the talent. I rate Firmino that highly, and I don't overrate any footballer, no matter how much I like him. Firmino has played in 5 different positions in his professional career, at the highest level and he's done it very well. What he's done for the youth teams for both club and country I have no interest in. Plenty of players have produced at such levels. If he is to be near in any skillset compared to Firmino he's going to have to show it for the first team.
Perhaps one day Brewster can be able to do the same Right now he isn't near any Bobby's attributes.
Perhaps it's your definition of ''near'' is the issue.
