What is your independent judgment of the two players?
Do you consider a 4-6 M quid price reasonable for Ince?
How much more are you going to get from Ince, based on your independent evaluation of his performances and potential, than Pacheco?
How much are WE going to get for Pacheco, given how infrequently he's had the chance to showcase his talent and improve? We've been playing Joe Cole, ffs, to put him (I hope that's the reason and not on perceived merit) on the proverbial shop window. What have we done to maximize the value of Pacheco to us in the transfer market?
We sold Ince to Blackpool for 250K with a 35% sell-on clause just 18 months ago. Now, it appears, we're willing to buy him back at an asking price of 6m (which will be reduced for us, given the above). What sense does that make? Is he really worth that much, based on his performances for Blackpool in the Championship?
Firstly, my independent judgement of the two players is a separate argument. I was talking about Dani's role at the club and the thinking of the man that matters, Brendan Rodgers, and all I was saying was that if he isn't getting a look in and isn't in the manager's thinking now, he probably won't be when (or if) our manager signs two more attacking players in Sturridge and Ince who would join the likes of Suarez, Borini, Shelvey, Sterling, Suso, Cole, Downing etc who are already ahead of Dani. To which you replied somewhat unnecessarily abruptly with that comment and "I don't know what's going on, I give up"!
I've not personally seen enough of Ince at senior level to truly evaluate his worth, and my opinion is hardly important compared to our manager's. But FWIW, I don't get to see Blackpool matches and all I know is that he looked like he had potential for us at youth level when I saw him on LFC TV, and he's done fantastically well there, scoring 13 goals and setting up nine in just 20 league games. I don't think clearly that selling so low and buying so high makes sense, but his performances in the Championship have been far more impressive than Dani's at Norwich. I don't think Dani has shown enough in a red shirt. Hopefully Ince will.
If Ince had never played for us and we were after a young player with such brilliant stats in the Championship for say £4m I would be excited and I think most fans would too. It doesn't seem extortionate when you take our prior ownership out of the equation. So I would say £4m is reasonable.
I don't think Dani has great worth in the transfer market sadly.