Topic: Football commentator/pundits

[elsewhere]

Warren Barton has to get some recognition as the worst, the fucking cretin

[JRed]

When did commentary become a fucking 90(+) minute conversation about fucking shite? Can’t bear it.

[slaphead]

One of the best I've seen in recent times has been Liam Rosenior. Speaks brilliantly about the game. Didn't realise he was managing Hull and looking like he's doing a good job at that

[bradders1011]

His dad Leroy used to be not terrible on the Football League Show back in the day.

[Pistolero]

Tyldsley and Shearer very good on Amazon tonight....even if the game itself wasnt

[slaphead]

Robbie Savage really needs to stop with this "right then Christopher" every single time he speaks to Chris Sutton.

[Ghost Town]

Robbie Savage really needs to stop with this "right then Christopher" every single time he speaks to Chris Sutton.

Especially as "Chris Sutton" and "right" simply don't go together

[FlashGordon]

One of the best I've seen in recent times has been Liam Rosenior. Speaks brilliantly about the game. Didn't realise he was managing Hull and looking like he's doing a good job at that

I've been championing him on here for years. Nedum Onouha is another solid pundit when I've seen him.

[Wabaloolah]

Robbie Savage really needs to stop with this "right then Christopher" every single time he speaks to Chris Sutton.

is Savage still claiming Ten Hag to be the world's best manager?

[Legs]

I've been championing him on here for years. Nedum Onouha is another solid pundit when I've seen him.

He is very good always has been.

Jobi Mcanuff is good too.

Probably why they dont get near PL games speak too much sense.

[Clint Eastwood]

Where's the thread for the worst pundit?

Anyway, I actually don't mind Neville as a pundit, but his commentary has been very strange tonight.

[Knight]

Neville needs to be stood down from Liverpool games. Probably Utd ones too. Very, very weird. And not in a good way.

[JRed]

Neville has to be taken off Liverpool games. He is a fucking disgrace.

[Terry de Niro]

Where's the thread for the worst pundit?

Anyway, I actually don't mind Neville as a pundit, but his commentary has been very strange tonight.

https://www.redandwhitekop.com/forum/index.php?topic=87496.msg1396145#msg1396145

[Skeeve]

You don't need commentators to be emotionless robots when doing games, but there should be at least a certain level of professionalism and keeping your personal biases off the air, which Neville doesn't even try to pretend to do.

[Jshooters]

Where's the thread for the worst pundit?

Anyway, I actually don't mind Neville as a pundit, but his commentary has been very strange tonight.

This is true. He’s not a bad pundit he just can’t hide his bias when he’s on LFC duty which makes it a fucking nightmare to listen to

[slaphead]

Neville needs to be stood down from Liverpool games. Probably Utd ones too. Very, very weird. And not in a good way.

ooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhhh can't think that you mean there ooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhh

[DiggerJohn]

I wonder if it's like that in the Italian Spanish or German leagues. Do they have fools like Rio Micah Rat and Bluenose. Surely they are more articulate and not so laddish. I remember on c4 back in the day James Richardson on football italia. I won't know what team he supported.

[Agent99]

"Oh no"

[decosabute]

This is true. He’s not a bad pundit he just can’t hide his bias when he’s on LFC duty which makes it a fucking nightmare to listen to

This is basically it. He's actually fine when analysing or commenting on most teams, but he really should be stood down from covering United or Liverpool. He's completely incapable of rational or balanced thought with either team. Genuinely loses his mind. Of course it'll never happen though, as Sky clearly want him spewing shite and enraging people to drive clicks and engagements.

[MonsLibpool]

I wonder if it's like that in the Italian Spanish or German leagues. Do they have fools like Rio Micah Rat and Bluenose. Surely they are more articulate and not so laddish. I remember on c4 back in the day James Richardson on football italia. I won't know what team he supported.

Spanish commentators are partisan and they are not shy about it which is a refreshing change from the sly commentary in the UK.

The French are more objective and professional, though, they have some dickheads like Nasri (who feels Alisson is overrated) and Dacourt who is an ex-bitter but it's not bad.

(I speak both languages and I have watched/listened to games in them).

[MonsLibpool]

This is basically it. He's actually fine when analysing or commenting on most teams, but he really should be stood down from covering United or Liverpool. He's completely incapable of rational or balanced thought with either team. Genuinely loses his mind. Of course it'll never happen though, as Sky clearly want him spewing shite and enraging people to drive clicks and engagements.

He's an idiot. I started putting him on mute after he said Arsenal are better than us. He even tried to justify why Odegaard's handball wasn't given as a pen.

[DiggerJohn]

Cheers thanks for the info would you know about south America too, the commentators for say river plate vs boca juniors. Surely they have to be neutral for personal safety

[eddiedingle]

Neville is a squealing ballbag. Him and Carraghers chuckle brothers act is truly odious.

[MonsLibpool]

Cheers thanks for the info would you know about south America too, the commentators for say river plate vs boca juniors. Surely they have to be neutral for personal safety

I don't know much about club football but they are very partisan when commentating on their national teams' games but in a good way.

[MonsLibpool]

Neville is a squealing ballbag. Him and Carraghers chuckle brothers act is truly odious.

Notice how he insidiously led an agenda against Darwin from day 1 when his team has bigger flops in Hojlund and Antony.

People take everything he says as gospel.

[DiggerJohn]

I don't know much about club football but they are very partisan when commentating on their national teams' games but in a good way.

And rightly so

[killer-heels]

The problem with Neville is not just his bias but as Carragher has pointed out, Neville cant make a prediction without a counter prediction because now he clearly wants to be right on everything.

At the start of the season on his fan Overlap shite, all the social media fan channels of other clubs said Liverpool would be up there this season in top four and yet Neville said he didnt think so. Then against Newcastle he said they would be too powerful for us at St James.

However when he made his top four prediction he had Liverpool in there. He was afraid we would be back so to cover himself he put us in his top four to avoid being called out on it.

[DangerScouse]

Fucking hell, Neville is an intolerable gobshite, utterly nauseating. His poor fucking missus when he's riding her, the squealing c*nt.

[OOS]

Neville views his football through a United 90s-00s Ferguson lens, that's his downfall. Like most players that owe their footballing success to Ferguson, they still don't understand why they won what they did. .

[FiSh77]

Fucking hell, Neville is an intolerable gobshite, utterly nauseating. His poor fucking missus when he's riding her, the squealing c*nt.

Don't talk about his ma like that, fucking disgusting

[lfc_col]

People take everything he says as gospel.

Its really baffling people the guy has nothing about him at all all the personality of a crisp packet

[slaphead]

hahaha Shearer losing his head over the pen. "fucking embarassing" and "worst dive ever" haha. What a hypocrite he is. How many times has he sat on TV and said you get contact you go down. Except when its against his team.
Didn't say anything about how we absolutely dominated Newcastle like

[slaphead]

Mark Goldbridge summed Neville up perfectly. He thinks he's the prime minister of football

[MH41]

Neville should be nowhere near our games. He always has an agenda. He just cannot be impartial when it comes to us.
Tonight he has accused Diaz and Jota of diving.
In similar situations in other games, he'll simply say "It's a clear penalty. The defender/keeper has been rash, and clipped him, and knocked him off balance", and there would be no further controversy.
Sky are the ones at fault though.
They don't want intelligent, insightful pundits, or co commentators. They want idiots like Neville, Keane and Carragher, who offer little, but controversy, and this adds traffic to their sites.

[killer-heels]

The nerve to call the Diaz one a dive. Its as clear a penalty as you will see.

[Gili Gulu]

I don't mind Neville at all, he usually reigns himself in when not watching us, but still comes up with some corkers where we're concerned like "Liverpool would want United's midfield".

But when he's watching us he absolutely loses his mind at time, he's so ridiculously biased. "Arsenal should take Liverpool on, they've got better players 1 to 11"

[Gili Gulu]

Neville views his football through a United 90s-00s Ferguson lens, that's his downfall. Like most players that owe their footballing success to Ferguson, they still don't understand why they won what they did. .

Mark Hughes was cursed by this after he left United, he was constantly bamboozled by the concept of not being given every single decision in a game.

[WhereAngelsPlay]

At the minute it is any on the P. Leagues international feed.

Except when it's Warnock.

[FiSh77]

Neville views his football through a United 90s-00s Ferguson lens, that's his downfall. Like most players that owe their footballing success to Ferguson, they still don't understand why they won what they did. .

Typical united fan under 50, can't remember them being wank so it's come as a complete shock and too thick to work out that this is the norm for them