My issue with the all time is you start to get Pele, Maradona etc. picks too, and it becomes to look more like other drafts whereas a current draft is pretty open to a lot of new players being drafted.
I do agree with this. It is a bit dull seeing the likes of Diego and Pele drafted over and over again. One solution would be to do a first round of banned picks. So each of us nominates a player who we don't want to see drafted. Depending on how many join the draft, that would see a about 12-16 obvious picks removed. Could possibly apply that to South Americans only as that might be a bit harsh on Africa, since historically they have far less GOATs.
Example banned players - Pele, Maradona, Messi, Garrincha, Ronaldo, Ronaldinho, Zico, Passarella, R. Carlos, Cafu, Suarez, Romario, Socrates, Kleberson etc