Red85 and Mikey a narrow one for me. Red85's defence just seems a weak link as a unit, given there's a left-back in right central defence, and between Chivu, Fachetti (the god) and Lichsteiner, I could see Chiellini being abandonded several times per game. On the other hand, Zoff was a top keeper, so you'd have to be a special striker to get one past him.
And that's where Mikey has an edge, I think. If there's one Serie A striker of the "Serie A golden age" of the 80s/90s who could fashion a goal out any impossible angle, distance, packed defence or top class keeper, it was van Basten. With Tevez and Laudrup to help out, and a pack of mean bastards in Mihajlovic, Samuel and Sensini to defend, fronted but Simeone, there can only be one winner (narrowly, as this game would probably be a midfield-heavy 1-0).
In the second game, Trend/Chakan have fashioned a decent side - Cannavaro and Materazzi as solid as you like, DeRossi holding, Hamsik carrying the attack, Nedved creating and Higuain and Cavani (not the fastest, but lethal in the box) finishing the final ball.
But I have Dossena and Tomas "Where's the nearest Domino's, and do they deliver?" Brolin.
So f*ck them