I’ve had a go and it makes you think about ‘why’. Why does a song make it onto a favourites list? Why would it be impossible not to include it?
For most of the ones on my list, it’s about anticipation. Knowing that there’s a moment in the song that always makes the hairs on my neck stand up, or knowing it’s part of an all time favourite album.
It’s also often about the moment you first heard it. I reckon there’s some kind of strange sweet spot where everything comes together. Your state of mind, who you’re with and where you are. A song can just stomp into your life at exactly the right moment and say, ‘I’m here and I’m gonna hit the spot and you’ll be hooked’. You might’ve heard it before and its beauty or genius might not have registered at that moment. The time wasn’t right. But suddenly it’s got you.
Not sure I could put them in order though….
Genesis - Supper’s Ready
Agree with Zeppelin on this one.
The Horrors - Sea within a sea
First time I heard this was at about 3am in a grungy bar in Spain. It stopped me in my tracks and I put my beer down to listen. At the end i legged it over to the DJ to ask him who it was, and he goes what sounded like “los orros”. Took me weeks to work out what he meant and find the song.
The Rolling Stones - Can’t You Hear Me Knocking
That opening, filthy riff would be enough on its own but the song then goes off on one with a great rambling instrumental.
Pixies - Debaser
Doolittle is up there with my favourite albums and Pixies my favourite bands, so I love hearing that opening bass line. Could’ve picked virtually any song by them.
Human League - The Sound of the Crowd
Just pure 80s. Makes you want to flick your wedge haircut over, dab on the old spice, and go on a night out.
Pink Floyd - Echoes
Like Pixies it could’ve been any number of Floyd tracks but Echoes just got the nod for that long, tense, post-cave section build up to the release before the final verse. Couldn’t be any other band that would do that. Has to be the 23 minute version on Meddle, not that 16 min imposter that appears on a few compilations.
The Stranglers - Down in the sewer
I’ve always loved The Stranglers, and in particular Dave Greenfield’s keyboard wizardry. The last couple of minutes they obviously just said, ‘go Ed Dave, give it some’.
Orbital - Out there somewhere Part 2
I spent every weekend for 6 years 88-93 dancing to music "wholly or predominantly characterised by the emission of a succession of repetitive beats," to quote from the Criminal Justice bill that finally squeezed all the fun out of that particular activity. That leaves a legacy on your musical tastes. I could do a top 20 faves from house and techno alone. A top 100 in fact, but that would be silly. This Orbital track is just one of those that you think to yourself, ‘I wish I knew how to produce that’. You can see that they’ve put thought and effort and layers into it; and it’s almost symphonic in the way it has different movements and eventually comes full circle to return to the original theme. No? Just me then
Carli Simon - Why
Has to be the extended 12” version. Just a beautiful voice and a lovely, moving song.
The The - Uncertain Smile
Again has to be the 12” which is rare as rocking horse shit but I’m lucky enough to have on vinyl. Bit of Jools Holland (much more on the album version) to go with Matt Johnson’s haunting lyrics.
The Raconteurs - The Switch and the Spur
Full of drama. And a western feel to it, which I love. Anything with a brass section gets my vote.
Colourbox - The Official Colourbox World Cup theme
Just makes me smile and usually has me pogo-ing up and down. Again, has to be the long version.
The Clash - Complete Control
Their best track for me by a country mile.
Half Man Half Biscuit - Corgi Registered Friends
One from the incomparable and unsurpassed ‘Achtung Bono’ album. Nigel Blackwell doing what he does best, taking the piss out of the mundane.
It’s been on my Rawk profile pic for years and I used to get PMs asking me for boiler advice!
The Who - Behind Blue Eyes
One of those anticipating a hairs on the neck moment. And it never fails. It’s that transition from a heart-on-the-sleeve ballad, to pure rock n roll via a sudden, almost unexpected sublime guitar. Whoosh…Every time. Who’s Next might be my favourite album ever.
The Cardiacs - Is This The Life
Just makes me headbang, every time.
Tame Impala - Let it happen
Strange one this. Something about it hooked me in and I feel the urge to listen to it quite a lot. Don’t know much about them really.
The Doors - LA Woman
Heard this at a festival and it was right time, place, company. I just thought ‘wow what a song!’
Galaxy 2 Galaxy - Hi-Tech Jazz
As someone summed it up in the YouTube comments: “Detroit. Soul. Funk. Warmth. Detroit. Magical. Techno. Happy times. Soul. Detroit. Smiles.” Couldn’t put it better myself.
Gil Scott Heron - Lady Day and John Coltrane
I love Gil, saw him a couple of times live and his voice was incredible. My sister got me into him after she saw him at the Royal Court in the 80s and then bought me his ‘Reflections’ album which is class from start to finish. Lady Day isn’t on it, but it’s just such an uplifting track that it had to make the cut.
Led Zep - When The Levee Breaks
Always loved it. Just a stone cold classic slice of rock n roll. Air guitar all over the show.
Supertramp - School
I could’ve picked one of 4 or 5 tracks off Crime of the Century. It was my dad’s favourite album so this one’s for him really. In the end I went for the opening track as once again, like Debaser on Doolittle, the opening bars prompt anticipation of the brilliant music to come. Plus there’s that great piano bit!
Enjoyed doing that (and listening to them all again). Nice one Timbo.
Can’t believe Bowie, Buzzcocks, Stevie Wonder, Julian Cope, Joy Division, Neil Young or The Beatles never made it on, but there you go.
Edit: proves one thing, I can’t count, there’s 22.