Criticism echoed from TV pundits? Having been to most the games this season, I completely disagree with all of the above. During that terrible spell earlier in the season, he played a lot of games and just didn't offer any movement/pressing/creativity up front. We barely had any shots on target during that period too. I do agree that he was isolated, but every time Coutinho/Sterling looked up he wouldn't run in behind. Even against Swansea we played really well, were 4-1 up and he came on and just didn't look convincing.
He started Borini because we need that pressing from the front and runs in behind. Even if he missed a sitter he still offered aggression from the front. Another reason was he was playing a club he was at for a year - knows how they play/shop window.
Having said this, I do hope Balotelli comes good and do rate him as a player. However, he is just the opposite of what we need in a striker, and target men just don't do well in Rodgers' system. It's all well and good saying give him a chance with Sturridge up front, however who are you going to drop out of Sterling/Coutinho/Lallana/Markovic to accommodate him? And that would mean changing the system that is currently changing our season around to accommodate him.
In the early part of the season when he was being slated by every pundit going, almost to a man in here fans were pointing out what he was doing right and bemoaning the fact that he wasn't getting the service that Suarez and Sturridge had been getting last year. The Rodgers drops him, and half of the band wagon jumpers skip immediately to "he' shit, he doesn't work hard, he doesn't make runs".
Its so boringly predictable.
Liverpool were playing shite football for months, right through the CL group stage period - Sterlina and Coutinho were terrible and half of the forum was saying that it was time for Stevie to take a rest (quickly forgotten also). Balotelli was settling in to the team at the exact time that we were god awful
He is not a "target man" by the way, I have no idea where you have got that idea from.
Balotelli is ten times the player that both Borini and Lambert are. Now lets go back a few months when we signed him and 95% of folks in here believed that Rodgers was the manager to figure out the enigma, and get him to perform. That little idealistic bit of idol worship seems to have been forgotten and no its "down to Mario".
I repeat, watch the team's attacking play in his last several substitute appearances and tell me we did not move up several gears the moment he got onto the pitch. You can even see the step up in gears that Stevie makes as soon as Balo walks on the pitch, immediately he is looking for him, because you can see he believes in the player. For some reason Brendan doesn't.
With regards with who is dropped to accomodate Balo alongside Daniel, if Daniel ever gets back from injury. I'll remind you that we are effectively playing 5 defenders right now, a system of play that was barely used last year when we had both Luis and Daniel available.
So, yeah I would drop Manquillo.