I don’t think it’s revisionism to say he was shocking in his last few seasons. He had a stellar first season, then good patches but there were always consistency issues, injury issues, concentration issues... I got pretty sick of the sight of him being caught out of position or beaten for headers. That said, he was often very important for us because I remember for much of his time here, we never really had any proper wingers or left backs, meaning the side was incredibly dependent on him for providing width.