Is it possible to love something and simultaneously think it's overrated?
I'm saying this as a massive Beach Boys fan, but...Pet Sounds.
There's great songs on it, production is incredible, etc.
Maybe it's the fact it, along with "What's Going On", "Sgt Peppers", "London Calling" were always, without fail at the top of best album ever polls in the NME, etc. Maybe the weight of expectation means they can never live up to the hype.
I reckon between those four albums you could make one truly great one!