I admitted he wasn't top drawer, D. Each team in the draft has a weakness but a Portuguese international, double cl winner, playing for Real Madrid, can hardly be described as a 'poor defender'. Also, Coentrau was a decent attacking force. Are we considering Ashley Cole as a 'great defender'?
Of course each team does have a weakness mate, I agree. But him being a double CL winner and playing for Real Madrid doesn't change that he didn't have his flaws as a defender. For one he played no part in their second CL win, bar two games in the group stages he played in. He wasn't even in the squad from 90 percent of their matches. He played 50 minutes in their first final there that he won with Madrid.
Ashley Cole is galaxies a better fullback and footballer mate, he wasn't the greatest defender but he was a good one, on both ends of the pitch. He certainly improved massively defensively when he went to Chelsea.
Perhaps poor was a bit harsh of a word.