For me Brendan Rodgers is like any player at the club, if we can bring somebody better then we do it.
In some ways it is indeed like players, if there is a better player we don't hesitate to upgrade if it is in our interests. My views on loyalty changed after Kenny was removed, I was happy to support a club managed by Kenny, regardless of success
(we did win something and made two wembley finals remember), because I felt an emotional attachment to the club and the management, now its just the club. That does not mean I would be abusive or unreasonable to any LFC manager(unless they deserved it of course) but ultimately, most managers are just employees like everyone else. I do favour stability but then success and stability I favour more.
It leaves us with choices.
1.
Upgrade the manager (twist, but based on the card), ultimately this can't be guaranteed if you hold think you have an ace that the next card will work out but it improves the chances, whoever the choice is. Past success, charisma, player respect all help to make better choices, there's one out there now, probably only one now.
2.
Stick, basically keep Brendan in the job, it almost impossible to know what the outcome is based on year 1 (average to poor), year 2, (fantastic, one of the best seasons, without a trophy, I can remember) and year 3 (piss poor, one of the worst full seasons I can remember). My worry is that the vision of the future we have been hinted at (Ings, Benteke and Milner) does not fill me with much optimism, I may be wrong, but sorry, it just doesn't.
3.
Twist (blind), remove the current manager then search for a new one, this would be stupid.
With players we often buy new before dispensing with old, everyone accepts this, its harder in management obviously but nevertheless it helps the upgrade process if that's what we choose. I'm for 1 if it can be done, especially if the opportunity, if not taken, is then lost. If we stick and someone like Klopp decides to take himself to say, West Ham with their shiny new stadium and London money, we could be kicking ourselves for many years.
If not then I will back Brendan fully, I'm sure he understand it, someone who holds out three envelopes to players saying who'll be gone if they don't perform, would surely understand, its a cruel world but no-one is going to starve.