Yeah exactly this. If you see the game tactically then players like Fabinho, Petit, Makelele, Mauro Silva - they win you titles. If we had Fabinho on the pitch on Saturday, we probably don't surrender territory and possession to Madrid. I mentioned after the game that I think Klopp will have a hard look at the core of the team now that have lost him 3 finals and ask tough questions. This is probably the first step there. Interesting times.
I touched on this in the post game thread, and it came up in the Van Dijk one recently too. I think this is spot on.
Think you can get away with one of Henderson and Milner in your midfield three, but not both. Not against that quality of opponent. In the second half in particular they seemed to have lost the confidence to turn on the ball. To play a one touch pass. To do the quick, basic things that we need when we play from the back. It's harsh to compare against Modric and Kroos, but because they were the opponents, *you* couldn't help but. To see them calmly ping the ball around the press that has reduced lesser players to quivering wrecks would have been a thing of beauty had it not been against us. To then see our deepest midfielder (whenever it was Henderson or Milner) receive the ball with about 10/12 yards of space, and not having the quality, or confidence in their quality to take it on the half turn, or pass first time with a weaker (or even stronger foot)... Well, I was sat there thinking we were going to struggle, and that was before Bale's goal (or even Benzema's I think)
In all honesty, I think this will be the end of Milners time in our midfield. He'll probably get games, but nowhere near the amount he has the last two season. I also think it's the season where Henderson finds himself as first backup. He'll still likely play 30 games, and he should. Those against the bottom 12, league and FA Cups, where we need to keep legs fresh. Just think if we're playing in next seasons Champions League final, we're more likely to see Henderson on the bench with Fabinho, Keita and then one from Ox/Lallana and hopefully Fekir.