Yep, you got too much unwarranted stick for what was a reasonable call at the time and an even more pertinent one as the trajectories of the two players pass each other like ships in the night
I first saw Nat in the pre season Torino friendly and he looked like a decent player then, played alongside Virg, but he wasn't going to be a starter any time soon with VVD, Matip, Lovren and Gomez all in front of him. I've also suffered seeing Slabhead due to the missus watching their games and I've seen him make mistake after mistake after mistake, costing a lot of goals. Maybe Maguire is better technically, although I've not seen it, but on pure doing your job, Nat does his time after time after time, while Maguire is a liability. He runs about like a headless chicken and causes more issues than he solves.
Klopp has admitted he made a mistake putting Fab and Hendo in the back 4 last season, I think he realised he should have trusted Nat and Rhys a lot sooner than he did.
I'm not so sure he will want to move on. Bit like Origi. They'll get a few games and they're part of something really special and the likelihood is they will win more things. People criticise players for staying when they're 3rd or 4th or 5th choice for having a lack of ambition but some players would rather play a a bit part for an elite team than a big part for a lesser team. I know lots of people don't like him bit Micah Richards was making that exact point the other night on Five Live and I agree with him, there's nothing wrong with it.
The role of the manager is key too. Klopp clearly has a great relationship with these lads, if they did move on it would be difficult to find someone as good to step in and then people have a go about squad depth again.
For a professional, playing for Liverpool, at Anfield and at places like the San Siro, being on the bench at these grounds, training at Kirkby every day with world class players, playing for Klopp, loving your job and picking up medals that matter, surely that is a dream job. I'd rather that than play week in week out for Burnley.