I agree he is the exact oposite, he wins titles for a start.
If Mourinho ever did manage us we would delighted with him instantly.
I don't think any fan with an ounce of understanding the club would be delighted instantly or otherwise.
He wins titles, true. But he wins them for himself not the club. The club is irrelevant to him.
The two biggest nights of his career, the two CL finals.
Were huge matches for his clubs at the time, years of European obscurity, suddenly the Champions of Europe.
Yet the images of those nights ingrained in our/their memory are not Javier Zanetti, one of the most loyal and outstanding footballers of his generation finally getting his reward and moment of glory lifting the cup or Porto's improbable cup run ending in glory and sights of delighted players and the crowd revelling in the moment......
No, they are the soft bastard ripping his medal off and pissing of down the tunnel, or him walking down the stairs for the personal lap of honour he felt he deserved. The cameras actually panned from Zanetti on the podium to watch this self congratulative bastard soak in his own glory.
I'm not turning this into a Rafa vs Mourinho thing. But compare the image of Mourinho post CL victories with Rafa stood on the back of the podium hugging Morientes and having a chat with a huge grin. That right there is what we want from a manager. Genius and humility in equal measure. Jose might speak 5 languages but he doesn't know the word humility in any of them.
I'd rather Liverpool not win another title than win it in the manner Mourinho does.
Even Mr Ferguson has the decency not to run all over the pitch and steal the moment from his players or supporters.
And its all irrelevant because it will never happen.