Trend and Viva make your cases, can't choose between them
Actually, I think Bobby's 4-5-1 might cause us a lot of problems on the counter. I would be worried about our right side with overlapping runs by Stielike and Brietner fed by Deco.
Also, Rivera, Cruyff and Van Persie and their combination play, angled runs are a real problem for any team. Their different skill sets poses a substantial pick your poison problem for my 3 CB's, even with outstanding wingbacks like we have in Schnellinger/Thuram.
I think the overall case to be made for Bobby is two fold:
1. Nice expression of a Dutch 4-3-3 formation, specific positioning to suit their strengths using German and Dutch players primarily with a few skill players who could play in any league in the world (Deco, Zubi) - at times it looks like a 4-2-4 and at others 4-3-3 (flexibility)
2. Johann Cruyff in a free role with talent all around him - makes everyone else better.
So, to get the to the finals, I would say we have a few "small" things to consider for team Trend.
First, allow me to say that I am not familiar with his CB pairing specifics (other than a little name recognition) - never saw them play. This does not mean much. I do like our 3 strong CB's with very different leadership styles/skills/talent in the middle of defense pushing Albertini/Case into midfield pressure pockets from which to squeeze the opposition between them (rock) and our front three (a hard place) from which to counter.
Second, I do like how our back 5 with wingbacks. They have the flexibility to control the defensive third of the pitch centrally and out wide -- especially with the doggedness of Case and Albertini covering centrally when Vogts or Ayala get pulled out.
Third, while I love Bobby's team shape - I like ours too. The free reign that Bobby's top three have is similar to ours -- except both our teams want to attack different spaces - who has the most success in doing so, I cannot tell you.
Lastly, I am not sure I can make the specific case our team is better, blah blah blah ----> but I can say whomever gets to the final, I think has a great chance to win the whole kit and kaboodle.
Good luck Viva, outstanding team you got there mate.