Topic: Who is the best pundit? 2021 edition

[gerrardisgod]

Michael Brown throwing out the stronger depth shout, they’re even loaning out promising youngsters now too. So not sure how he works that out.

[El Lobo]

BBC predictions are up. Rob Green has United finishing 2nd ahead of us.

He's probably seen them loan out Henderson, sign Tom Huddlestone and thought....maybe, just maybe

[sinnermichael]

Michael Brown throwing out the stronger depth shout, they’re even loaning out promising youngsters now too. So not sure how he works that out.

Ex Man City player talking shite. Shock.

Richards has gone for City to win it which I'm really shocked by. Probably gets royalties from the club for blowing smoke up their arse.

[killer-heels]

Watched that 'Overlap' show that Neville and Carragher present. Why do they insist on getting football fan media to represent the clubs they show. Cant they just get normal fans?

[Bread]

Watched that 'Overlap' show that Neville and Carragher present. Why do they insist on getting football fan media to represent the clubs they show. Cant they just get normal fans?

To be fair, we're one of the lucky ones in that Paul Machin is a fairly articulate and logical presence to represent the club.

Imagine being represented by AFTV or Adam McKola.

[killer-heels]

To be fair, we're one of the lucky ones in that Paul Machin is a fairly articulate and logical presence to represent the club.

Imagine being represented by AFTV or Adam McKola.

Thankfully that mad man from Arsenal with the headphones wasn't on. Its embarrassing, but at the same time quite disturbing.

[Crosby Nick]

Thankfully that mad man from Arsenal with the headphones wasn't on. Its embarrassing, but at the same time quite disturbing.

This guy?

[Fazak_Red]

To be fair, we're one of the lucky ones in that Paul Machin is a fairly articulate and logical presence to represent the club.

Imagine being represented by AFTV or Adam McKola.

Or being represented by a brass like Chelsea.

[Jwils21]

Watched that 'Overlap' show that Neville and Carragher present. Why do they insist on getting football fan media to represent the clubs they show. Cant they just get normal fans?

Agreed, football fan media "pundits" are always going to be skewed in what they say as they go for what will generate the most attention rather than what they actually think.

[slaphead]

BBC predictions are up. Rob Green has United finishing 2nd ahead of us.

Little bit worrying that Jermaine Jenas, Clinton Morrison and Chris Sutton have us winning it. JJ should stick to Question Time. His analysis on Utd is very very tired and lazy

"This is not Ronaldo at the peak of his powers, like when he won the Champions League with United in 2008 and he was indispensable and had so much influence on the team. But this Ronaldo is vital in terms of his goal contribution to United. If they lose the 24 goals he scored for them last season, who gets them? "

I think we worked out by now this isn't 2008, and how about looking at how many goals the team scored every season before that petulant fucker came back

[voodoo ray]

the bbc predictions were so bad last year you'd have got more accuracy if you'd asked some mice to pick by shitting on a dartboard.

[spen71]

I’ve watched quite a lot of the commonwealth games.    The standard of commentary and pundits is light years ahead of the football lot

[gerrardisgod]

Not too sure if their picture lineups are 100% definite, but it indicates that BT have also jibbed Macca from their PL lineup too.

[The G in Gerrard]

Not too sure if their picture lineups are 100% definite, but it indicates that BT have also jibbed Macca from their PL lineup too.

No Jake Humphries as the leading presenter for Premier League.

[Knight]

BBC predictions are up. Rob Green has United finishing 2nd ahead of us.

Someone should find out where he lives and pop round to see if he’s ok.

[Agent99]

Not too sure if their picture lineups are 100% definite, but it indicates that BT have also jibbed Macca from their PL lineup too.

[Clint Eastwood]

Can we change the title to just generic pundit discussion? Because we also talk about the worst pundits here.

Speaking of which, Martin Tyler with a disgusting comment on BBC R4 this morning. Talking about the start of Sky Sports, said “we weren’t that long after Hillsborough and other hooligan-related events.”

He’s always seemed to have something against us. Hopefully R4 correct the record.

[Barneylfc∗]

What a fucking scumbag

[slaphead]

I'll give him the benefit of the doubt and say that he didn't mean to link Hillsborough and hooliganism together in the way it sounds.  If I'm wrong and he did, he should never be allowed to commentate on our games again, and should also apologize. That's so hurtful of a comment if he meant it

[has gone odd]

voted ally mccoist, he is clearly streets ahead of other commentators, says it how it is and with a good sense of humour.

[Red46]

I'll give him the benefit of the doubt and say that he didn't mean to link Hillsborough and hooliganism together in the way it sounds.  If I'm wrong and he did, he should never be allowed to commentate on our games again, and should also apologize. That's so hurtful of a comment if he meant it

Yeah sometimes words come out not quite how you mean them to. Saying that if he genuinely was linking the 2 it’s beyond disgraceful, given what he does for a living he of all people should know better

[Spezialo]

voted ally mccoist, he is clearly streets ahead of other commentators, says it how it is and with a good sense of humour.

I agree.

[MJD-L4]

I'll give him the benefit of the doubt and say that he didn't mean to link Hillsborough and hooliganism together in the way it sounds.  If I'm wrong and he did, he should never be allowed to commentate on our games again, and should also apologize. That's so hurtful of a comment if he meant it

The BBC & Tyler have both apologised although I think he knew exactly what he was saying.

He's an outdated dinosaur with the propensity to make scummy as fuck comments like that. Don't ever want him near a commentary gantry again.

[Barneylfc∗]

The BBC & Tyler have both apologised although I think he knew exactly what he was saying.

He's an outdated dinosaur with the propensity to make scummy as fuck comments like that. Don't ever want him near a commentary gantry again.

No doubt about it. So many other ways he could've worded it and would've been very clear he wasn't conflating the 2, but he chose to imply Hillsborough was linked to hooliganism.

[Skeeve]

No doubt about it. So many other ways he could've worded it and would've been very clear he wasn't conflating the 2, but he chose to imply Hillsborough was linked to hooliganism.

Indeed, he's been forced to weasel out of it, but he definitely knew what he was doing by including the word other in that sentence, he's paid to speak for a living after all.

[oojason]

Can we change the title to just generic pundit discussion? Because we also talk about the worst pundits here.

Speaking of which, Martin Tyler with a disgusting comment on BBC R4 this morning. Talking about the start of Sky Sports, said “we weren’t that long after Hillsborough and other hooligan-related events.”

He’s always seemed to have something against us. Hopefully R4 correct the record.

A decent thread on Martin Tyler's abhorrent, yet clear and concise, comments now here, mate - www.redandwhitekop.com/forum/index.php?topic=352847.0


Tyle is a cnut - and the BBC too for letting such comments slide - yet again.

[Ghost Town]

I hate Steve McManaman

[reddebs]

Just fuck off Jenus!

[redgriffin73]

Had to mute it. They are awful.

[slaphead]

What's Gary Neville going on about now:

"The coach needs time so I won't have a go at him. And it comes a time where I won't even have a go at the players anymore. If you have a business and the people in that business can't do the job for you then you remove them from the business.

"It's abuse to keep them in the job for longer as they don't enjoy it either"

12 months ago it was - Varane + Sancho + Kane = Title remember that rat boy

[Enders]

'He never stops moving........... apart from when he stands still..'

Jermaine Penarse, Craven Cottage, Aug 6th 2022

[spen71]

What a contrast

Gabby Logan

Karen bloody  Carney

[tubby]

TIL Klopp listens to TalkSport.

[The G in Gerrard]

What a contrast

Gabby Logan

Karen bloody  Carney

Gabby is great and under used by the BBC.

[bird_lfc]

Klopp destroying gabby Agbonlahor is not a headline I expected to see today lol

[Nitramdorf]

Saw an ad last night for League of their Own. Never seen it but know how shit it is, it now has Micah Richards as a regular panel member. Imagine watching that. Pure torture.

[IgorBobbins]

Saw an ad last night for League of their Own. Never seen it but know how shit it is, it now has Micah Richards as a regular panel member. Imagine watching that. Pure torture.

[JRed]

Saw an ad last night for League of their Own. Never seen it but know how shit it is, it now has Micah Richards as a regular panel member. Imagine watching that. Pure torture.

I used to watch it now and then, but now Abu Dhabi have paid for that clown to be on , I will never watch it again.

[oojason]

“If it wasn’t for Liverpool, this fucking league would be shit.” -  Ian Wright.

^ https://twitter.com/Watch_LFC/status/1561431233237852161 (with 30 second video)

[Pistolero]

“If it wasn’t for Liverpool, this fucking league would be shit.” -  Ian Wright.

^ https://twitter.com/Watch_LFC/status/1561431233237852161 (with 30 second video)

This needs more love....