Bancroft for me. No contest.
Didn't notice any resemblance before, but they do have an ever-so-slight similarity to their faces when you look at a pic like that... like if it flashed up and disappeared very quickly, you might well mistake them for one another. But they each have very distinctive looks really.
Thing about Hathaway for me is that she's a very unusual beauty, almost cartoonishly so, but to a tasteful degree that is just perfect. I mean in that odd way that not-quite-perfect is more perfect than perfect! Wabi-sabi. She has a slightly alien, weird, exotic look about her. Absolutely huge expressive (and often quite adorably sad) eyes, full rosy lips, very fair skin, very dark hair, a truly knockout feminine figure... Snow White with a certain Eastern quality about her.
Hathaway is the only way for me.