Following both threads, it's clear we're getting into Aquilani vs Adam territory again.
I'm not sure why. It won't end well for Charlie.
absolutely, there is no comparison, i think what tends to happen is that some of the arguments get regurgitated about each player and then compared either favourably or unfavourably used......no need to compare the 2, in that i doubt either will be shoe-ins at the start of the season, and quite possibly both could be not here by then....there the comparisons end, not the same sort of player
tend to stick with assertion that adam may be protected by a system where we are more compact and it will suit him somewhat to have discipline instilled into his game in the system we expect from rodgers, whether his strengths provide enough is the question posed i think