Was Kuyt only awful for you last season? I've been reading RAWK for years and it seems every season there is a long thread largelly criticising Kuyt and asking why Rafa keeps picking him etc, and then he'll have a run of form for 5-10 games and all will be forgiven and people will start talking about how hard he works etc. But for the majority of the time he's been with you, isn't a more honest reflection that his lack of ability has frustrated, but you've grown fond of him? I think because he's become seen as almost part of the furniture he'll go down as a good signing, but I'm not sure thats a true reflection of what I've seen of him at Liverpool or what I've read at RAWK for most of his time with you.