Author Topic: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership  (Read 260539 times)

Offline Yorkykopite

  • Misses Danny Boy with a passion.
  • RAWK Writer
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 18,338
  • The first five yards........
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1640 on: March 2, 2012, 03:04:21 PM »
I think with Pique they had an embarrassment of riches Ferdinand and Vidic were a top drawer pairing and then they had Evans and Shawcross who were top quality young Centre backs who were exactly the same age as Pique. Pique was brought in as a Defensive midfield player who grew into the stature of a centre back.

Luckily for the rest of the League it was during that period of adjustment that the Bolton game came about. We have no embarrassment of riches and unless Kelly is switched inside then Coates has pretty much a free run as a young centre back at the Club. We need to trust in his ability and his character and not make the mistake of stalling his career.

He is way beyond the realms of reserve team football or being loaned out and needs to start getting game time otherwise we could end up damaging his development.

I'm not denying what you say here. But let's not get cacrried away by the idea that Ferguson is infallible. He made a stupid choice when he ditched Pique. He panicked. And he's already paid for it in two European Cup finals, thank god.
"If you want the world to love you don't discuss Middle Eastern politics" Saul Bellow.

Offline stevedo

  • Lacks Emotion.
  • RAWK Supporter
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 5,800
  • Muddling through.
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1641 on: March 2, 2012, 03:05:51 PM »
Has he kept on many players too long? Giggs and Scholes may get laughed at for being pensioners but Scholes IMO is playing better than he has done in the last couple of years and Giggs is still performing well. The defence is the biggest example, Pique aside, with the likes of Smalling and Jones playing frequently. He did the same with Evans IIRC when his first choices were out.
I don't believe he does keep them too long, they're still good players, not at the heights they were but can still do (more than) a job. That's what I was getting at. He keeps them around until they retire (Neville, Van deSar, Scholes already!). He doesn't offload when they're on the downward slope, this is more what Wenger used to do. Now they leave Arsenal in their prime.
« Last Edit: March 2, 2012, 03:11:30 PM by stevedo »

Offline Hazell

  • Hyzenthlay. The 5th Benitle's sex conch.
  • RAWK Supporter
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 43,617
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1642 on: March 2, 2012, 03:10:08 PM »
I don't believe he does keep them too long, they're still good players, not at the heights they were but can still do (more than) a job. That's what I was getting at. He keeps them around until they retire (Neville, Van deSar, Scholes already!)

Oh ok, I misunderstood. What we should be doing is similar, if they're good enough. I don't think Carragher falls into that category.
We have to change from doubter to believer. Now.

Offline Mr Dilkington

  • would rather be too cold than too hot
  • RAWK Scribe
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 11,117
  • Never buy the Sun
    • www.level3football.com
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1643 on: March 2, 2012, 03:15:01 PM »
I'm not denying what you say here. But let's not get cacrried away by the idea that Ferguson is infallible. He made a stupid choice when he ditched Pique. He panicked. And he's already paid for it in two European Cup finals, thank god.
My understanding of the situation is Ferguson wanted to keep him, but Queiroz persuaded him that he was surplus to requirements and that Evans was the better player.
You change all the lead, sleeping in my head, as the day grows dim, I hear you sing a golden hymn.

Offline Red Genius

  • Part of the Neville clan. Voted "Most misnamed RAWKite" 2009-10. Reformed Coprophagiac
  • RAWK Supporter
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 8,508
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1644 on: March 2, 2012, 03:17:10 PM »
My understanding of the situation is Ferguson wanted to keep him, but Queiroz persuaded him that he was surplus to requirements and that Evans was the better player.

Fly on the wall in the ole drunks office eh?

Can't believe for one moment that stubborn prick would allow his decision making to be determined by somebody else.
"I have been privileged and lucky to wear the legendary red shirt. No one can take it away from me. YNWA, I don't have to walk alone because Liverpool FC will always be in my heart."

The Legend - Sami Hyypia

Offline Al 555

  • Number 1 is Carragher. Number 2 is Carragher. Number 3 is Carragher. Number 4 is Carragher. Likes to play God in his spare time.
  • RAWK Scribe
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 14,523
  • JFT 96
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1645 on: March 2, 2012, 03:48:11 PM »
I'm not denying what you say here. But let's not get cacrried away by the idea that Ferguson is infallible. He made a stupid choice when he ditched Pique. He panicked. And he's already paid for it in two European Cup finals, thank god.

I don't think it's a case of fallibility Yorkie, I think the choice between Evans, Pique and Shawcross was a subjective call on which player would turn out to be the best long term player. With hindsight Ferguson thankfully got it horrendously wrong he quite clearly chose to give the game time to the wrong player.

What he didn't do though was not give the game time to any of the young up and coming players and that for me is a far bigger error. It is abundantly clear which of the two options for centre back against Arsenal has a chance of a long term future in the side and which players development is going to benefit from game time and it sure as hell isn't the fella from Bootle.

One thing does need to be said: in the post-Benitez era, there was media-led clamour (but also some politicking going on at the club) to make the club more English; the idea being that the club had lost the very essence of what it means to be ‘Liverpool’. Guillem Ballague 18/11/10

Offline scatman

  • Slutty enough to make Jordan blush - and hard enough to piss in the wrong bush! Missing a shift key.
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 16,239
  • This is my world, you just WORK here :D
    • directions to football stadiums
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1646 on: March 2, 2012, 03:50:03 PM »
Fly on the wall in the ole drunks office eh?

Can't believe for one moment that stubborn prick would allow his decision making to be determined by somebody else.
You say that, but then in recent times under Fergie their best seasons were when Carlos Q was assistant, so he must have been taking some stuff on board from Carlos.

Though Fergie also fucked up with Stam..so he's not always right..
Would sacrifice Fordy in a sacred Mayan ritual to have him as the next Liverpool manager
Football stadiums in England

Offline Lent§

  • RAWK Stuff
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 17,361
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1647 on: March 2, 2012, 03:52:27 PM »
Stam was on steroids though, so Ferguson had his hand forced.
psn = Lents123

Offline scatman

  • Slutty enough to make Jordan blush - and hard enough to piss in the wrong bush! Missing a shift key.
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 16,239
  • This is my world, you just WORK here :D
    • directions to football stadiums
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1648 on: March 2, 2012, 04:02:42 PM »
Stam was on steroids though, so Ferguson had his hand forced.

He didnt get banned for long though :P didnt Rio get a longer ban? :D
Would sacrifice Fordy in a sacred Mayan ritual to have him as the next Liverpool manager
Football stadiums in England

Offline Yorkykopite

  • Misses Danny Boy with a passion.
  • RAWK Writer
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 18,338
  • The first five yards........
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1649 on: March 2, 2012, 04:10:16 PM »
I don't think it's a case of fallibility Yorkie, I think the choice between Evans, Pique and Shawcross was a subjective call on which player would turn out to be the best long term player. With hindsight Ferguson thankfully got it horrendously wrong he quite clearly chose to give the game time to the wrong player.

What he didn't do though was not give the game time to any of the young up and coming players and that for me is a far bigger error. It is abundantly clear which of the two options for centre back against Arsenal has a chance of a long term future in the side and which players development is going to benefit from game time and it sure as hell isn't the fella from Bootle.

Yes, Ferguson has always been willing to throw young players into big situations, it's true. Bob Paisley did this too.  I hope Kenny plays Seb Coates tomorrow for reasons which have been amply covered in many posts above. But I'm not expecting him to. Carragher is a mighty institution and - odd as it seems to say this - Kenny is not yet in a great position to administer the final blow. He's done a lot to reduce Carragher's prestige this season by putting him on the bench. But he'd be asking for an unnecessary battle right now if he promoted the claims of the new boy on the block over and above the gnarled old centre back in the fixture v Arsenal.

I'll be absolutely amazed if Coates starts. 
"If you want the world to love you don't discuss Middle Eastern politics" Saul Bellow.

Offline Vulmea

  • Almost saint-like.....
  • RAWK Scribe
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 4,303
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1650 on: March 2, 2012, 04:30:03 PM »
all the discussion about Coates, Kenny's just as likely to pick Kelly with Carrra in centre mid and Shelvey at left back
The great enemy of the truth is very often not the lie — deliberate, contrived and dishonest — but the myth — persistent, persuasive and unrealistic.

John F. Kennedy/Shanklyboy.

Offline Al 555

  • Number 1 is Carragher. Number 2 is Carragher. Number 3 is Carragher. Number 4 is Carragher. Likes to play God in his spare time.
  • RAWK Scribe
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 14,523
  • JFT 96
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1651 on: March 2, 2012, 04:32:02 PM »
Yes, Ferguson has always been willing to throw young players into big situations, it's true. Bob Paisley did this too.  I hope Kenny plays Seb Coates tomorrow for reasons which have been amply covered in many posts above. But I'm not expecting him to. Carragher is a mighty institution and - odd as it seems to say this - Kenny is not yet in a great position to administer the final blow. He's done a lot to reduce Carragher's prestige this season by putting him on the bench. But he'd be asking for an unnecessary battle right now if he promoted the claims of the new boy on the block over and above the gnarled old centre back in the fixture v Arsenal.

I'll be absolutely amazed if Coates starts. 

So will I and it is a pretty sad indictment of modern football that managers have to worry about things other than picking the best 11.
One thing does need to be said: in the post-Benitez era, there was media-led clamour (but also some politicking going on at the club) to make the club more English; the idea being that the club had lost the very essence of what it means to be ‘Liverpool’. Guillem Ballague 18/11/10

Offline socrates the sophist

  • No new LFC topics
  • Kopite
  • ****
  • Posts: 791
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1652 on: March 2, 2012, 04:38:01 PM »
I don't think we're "terrified" of playing Coates, but you're largely correct about Ferguson.

Not that Ferguson's record is unblemished when it comes to blooding young centre backs. Smalling, May and Jones are now being given the benefit of the doubt that was denied the best of them all - Pique. Ferguson really fucked up over Pique. A single, high-profile, mistake against Bolton Wanderers resulted in Pique being deprived a second chance and, eventually, being given a transfer to a small European team who had no other choice but to play a raw young centre half. 

I think the standard should be "is he good enough?" and not he is too young or on the other part of the scale "he's a copa winner"

From what we have seen so far Coates made too many mistakes when he played, Carra has been more solid. Hence, Carra should play.

May be next season Coates will gain more playing time.

Offline Neil D

  • The new Kop pin-up model. Met Momo in the ASDA.
  • RAWK Supporter
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 16,318
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1653 on: March 2, 2012, 04:48:02 PM »
Absolutely spot on Coates has far more experience than Phil Jones or Chris Smalling had when they arrived at Old Trafford yet Ferguson didn't think twice about playing Jones or Smalling.

Disagree, Phil Jones had played in the Premier League for two seasons, in the second in 25 games I think and in his second season he was superb. He was already a very good defender at Blackburn and was ready to walk into United's team. Jones has more experience at this level in this country than Coates and for me looks a top class player for years to come. If we had signed him in the summer I doubt very much we would have signed Coates and I also think Jones would be at least our third choice now and ahead of Carra because he is that good.
If you're visiting Crete, Greece or any of the Greek islands please take a minute to visit www.findstevencook.co.uk and find out about a missing Red and his family who need your help. Cheers

Offline Rohit

  • nol
  • RAWK Supporter
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 6,919
  • We all Live in a Red and White Kop
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1654 on: March 2, 2012, 04:52:54 PM »
Disagree, Phil Jones had played in the Premier League for two seasons, in the second in 25 games I think and in his second season he was superb. He was already a very good defender at Blackburn and was ready to walk into United's team. Jones has more experience at this level in this country than Coates and for me looks a top class player for years to come. If we had signed him in the summer I doubt very much we would have signed Coates and I also think Jones would be at least our third choice now and ahead of Carra because he is that good.

Phil jones looks at a top class player to come, come on neil have you seen him at this season. Talent as he is, he is a diaster at centre back and his been this season for man united, positionally he is awful and he is pretty short so has a problem dealing with high balls which has been exposed a number of times this year. Only difference now is jones is under spot light compared to his blackburn days where he played a significant number of games in midfield or a back 5. Jones has been vastly overrated and theres a reason ferguson has moved him to right back and midfield.

Offline MassDriver

  • Custom Tit... Shithouse lover... Politically correct and metrosexual cave dweller.
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 4,518
  • Hasta la victoria siempre
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1655 on: March 2, 2012, 04:57:21 PM »
Phil jones looks at a top class player to come, come on neil have you seen him at this season. Talent as he is, he is a diaster at centre back and his been this season for man united, positionally he is awful and he is pretty short so has a problem dealing with high balls which has been exposed a number of times this year. Only difference now is jones is under spot light compared to his blackburn days where he played a significant number of games in midfield or a back 5. Jones has been vastly overrated and theres a reason ferguson has moved him to right back and midfield.

Exactly.  Another overrated over-hyped English defender. Just like Cahill and Dann , players who were "clearly better" than Skrtel , who is supposed to be a "disaster waiting to happen".

Coates is a better prospect than Jones and not that far behind in his development curve.
You will never walk alone , Shanklyboy. RIP.

I am the Eye in the Sky, looking at you, I can read your mind. I am the maker of rules, dealing with fools, I can cheat you blind. Looking at you, I can read your mind

Offline Hazell

  • Hyzenthlay. The 5th Benitle's sex conch.
  • RAWK Supporter
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 43,617
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1656 on: March 2, 2012, 04:59:23 PM »
Whoever said the likes of Cahill and Dann were clearly better than Skrtel?
We have to change from doubter to believer. Now.

Offline MassDriver

  • Custom Tit... Shithouse lover... Politically correct and metrosexual cave dweller.
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 4,518
  • Hasta la victoria siempre
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1657 on: March 2, 2012, 05:02:12 PM »
Whoever said the likes of Cahill and Dann were clearly better than Skrtel?

Some of our more esteemed colleagues on RAWK.  I clearly remember having 'colorful' debates about the same in many a Skrtel/central defence topic.
You will never walk alone , Shanklyboy. RIP.

I am the Eye in the Sky, looking at you, I can read your mind. I am the maker of rules, dealing with fools, I can cheat you blind. Looking at you, I can read your mind

Offline Red Genius

  • Part of the Neville clan. Voted "Most misnamed RAWKite" 2009-10. Reformed Coprophagiac
  • RAWK Supporter
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 8,508
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1658 on: March 2, 2012, 05:08:18 PM »
Some of our more esteemed colleagues on RAWK.  I clearly remember having 'colorful' debates about the same in many a Skrtel/central defence topic.

Come on spit out those names... lets name and shame the best of them :)
"I have been privileged and lucky to wear the legendary red shirt. No one can take it away from me. YNWA, I don't have to walk alone because Liverpool FC will always be in my heart."

The Legend - Sami Hyypia

Offline Al 555

  • Number 1 is Carragher. Number 2 is Carragher. Number 3 is Carragher. Number 4 is Carragher. Likes to play God in his spare time.
  • RAWK Scribe
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 14,523
  • JFT 96
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1659 on: March 2, 2012, 05:13:15 PM »
Disagree, Phil Jones had played in the Premier League for two seasons, in the second in 25 games I think and in his second season he was superb. He was already a very good defender at Blackburn and was ready to walk into United's team. Jones has more experience at this level in this country than Coates and for me looks a top class player for years to come. If we had signed him in the summer I doubt very much we would have signed Coates and I also think Jones would be at least our third choice now and ahead of Carra because he is that good.


Here is Phil Jones career before this season



and

Seb Coates career before this season



It is abundantly clear which player had the most experience the one who has been playing Top flight Uruguayan Football, had reached the semi final of the South American equivalent of the Champions League, had played in the U20 World Cup and the South American U20 Championship and the one who had won both the Copa America title and the Copa America best young player.

We need to start remembering which team reached the semi's of the World Cup and which Country is it's continents Champions.
One thing does need to be said: in the post-Benitez era, there was media-led clamour (but also some politicking going on at the club) to make the club more English; the idea being that the club had lost the very essence of what it means to be ‘Liverpool’. Guillem Ballague 18/11/10

Offline Buzz Killington

  • Winner of RAWK's sexiest adolescent, as awarded by the Rt. Hon. CJ Parker
  • RAWK Supporter
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 5,890
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1660 on: March 2, 2012, 05:14:07 PM »
Funnily enough, in some cases the same few were banging on about Mata being flavour of the month.

Offline Lent§

  • RAWK Stuff
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 17,361
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1661 on: March 2, 2012, 05:15:00 PM »
Funnily enough, in some cases the same few were banging on about Mata being flavour of the month.
I'd rather have Matt Jarvis.



;)
psn = Lents123

Offline ArgImAPirate

  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 1,020
  • rat a tat tat
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1662 on: March 2, 2012, 05:16:16 PM »
I think the standard should be "is he good enough?" and not he is too young or on the other part of the scale "he's a copa winner"

From what we have seen so far Coates made too many mistakes when he played, Carra has been more solid. Hence, Carra should play.

May be next season Coates will gain more playing time.

I'm sorry, but I just don't agree. I think Carragher has made more mistakes this season. Or at very least, has made the same number of mistakes. Coates has had some bad moments, but he's also had some brilliant moments. He's got pace, height, and youth on his side. Carragher's got experience and leadership ability. Both players provide something important.

I think it's close between a legend on his last legs and a young player with a promising CV looking to prove himself.

Offline Hazell

  • Hyzenthlay. The 5th Benitle's sex conch.
  • RAWK Supporter
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 43,617
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1663 on: March 2, 2012, 05:17:24 PM »
Some of our more esteemed colleagues on RAWK.  I clearly remember having 'colorful' debates about the same in many a Skrtel/central defence topic.

Hmmm, strange. I know people thought he wasn't good enough but still.
We have to change from doubter to believer. Now.

Offline MassDriver

  • Custom Tit... Shithouse lover... Politically correct and metrosexual cave dweller.
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 4,518
  • Hasta la victoria siempre
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1664 on: March 2, 2012, 05:19:55 PM »
Come on spit out those names... lets name and shame the best of them :)

I am meticulously searching my old posts to find those nuggets.  ;D

Hmmm, strange. I know people thought he wasn't good enough but still.

Oh yeah.  I got all kinds of grief for defending Skrtel and was called a fanboy and what not.
You will never walk alone , Shanklyboy. RIP.

I am the Eye in the Sky, looking at you, I can read your mind. I am the maker of rules, dealing with fools, I can cheat you blind. Looking at you, I can read your mind

Offline Aristotle

  • is a bugger for the bottle. Apache tool wielder extraordinaire - especially in wardrobes. The 'Oral B' Specialist.....brushes his cavities vigorously outdoors.
  • RAWK Scribe
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 14,441
  • Happiness depends upon ourselves
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1665 on: March 2, 2012, 05:29:24 PM »
People seem to think that Coates is some inexperienced, weak minded player. He's a 2 time league winning player with Nacional, he won the Copa America with Uruguay, picking up best young player in the process. He has nearly 70 professional games and he has already shown that he has a great mentality by overcoming an absolute stinker against Stoke, into a great performance in the second half which, ironically enough, coincided with Carragher leaving the pitch.


Forget history, I may not have seen enough of Coates to claim that he's guaranteed to step up to the plate against Arsenal. But I've seen enough to think he warrants a fair shot at it, and I've seen enough of Carragher that I don't think he should be anywhere near the starting line-up. He slows down play, is terrible on the ball for a professional footballer, drags us deep onto the pitch and doesn't offer up an attacking threat in set pieces. And even if Coates makes mistakes, and I'm sure he will, worst case scenario it's a learning curve. Like we know he won't let a loose ball bounce like he did with Walters. If Carra does it, he won't take anything away from it. If they both start and make 3 mistakes leading to goals, at least 2-3 years down the line we can look back at that with Coates. Carra has already peaked and playing him is only delaying the inevitable

Just dawned on me why this is so familiar. Funny how this debate always pops up regarding Carragher. I could've sworn this same thing 

Quote from: Aristotle
How is it disrespectful? He has done wonderful things in the past. He's spent his entire career here. He's won everything possible, but the league title and his achievements with the club all deserve to be remembered. But how is he different to all of our other great players who were all shown the door without hesitation when the time came, with many of them winning significantly more at the club.
Emlyn Hughes made way for Hansen as you have stated yourself, and there's not a single person in the world who will say that was the wrong decision, yet you have no problem claiming that Coates isn't anywhere near Hansen's ability despite having seen him play a grand total of 2 games for the club. Emlyn Hughes was a European Cup and league winning captain, who also captained England. He had over 600 games with the club and he was replaced by an 18 year old center back from the lower divisions.

Coates is already a league winning player, who most recently picked up a Copa America winners medal and in the mean time picked up the award for best young players and that's hardly a small thing, considering the wealth of talent that South-America has prodoced constantly since the the 1920's.
Hughes was replaced by a much younger, inexperienced player. Despite being more than 3 years younger at the time than Carragher is now. Carra is getting older and his performances have shown with an alarming frequency that his body can't handle playing week in week out. It's biologically inevitable and despite many claiming it, Carragher is not in the league of the Baresis, Maldinis, Nestas of the game in the way that he can play every game into his late 30's without breaking a sweat.
His game has never been about that. He'll take a bullet for you, and deserves credit for that. But his game is more sliding tackles and clearing off the line, playing with cramps in every muscle in his legs whilst preventing a shot. It's never been about seeing the play in front of him and intercepting a pass by making 2-3 side steps or winning the ball in his own box and running the length of the pitch into the opposition's box.

And why is it so dangerous replacing Carragher? We're dropping points with him in the team, we might drop a few more or we might gain a few more we'll never know until we actually do it. And as Yorky said earlier about Hansen.
Quote from: Yorkykopite
So you'll remember his first season in Liverpool colours? I loved him from the off, but only his Mum would say he didn't make some howlers. I mean real howlers - the Man City and Man Utd away games in the first few weeks of Hansen's career remain lodged in my memory. Yours too, since you're a professional. But you know better than me that we stuck with him and saw him grow and were rewarded at the end of the season by being crowned European Champions. Why did we stick with him despite those head-in-hands moments? Because it was evident to everyone that the lad's all-round game was full of potential and that once he became more battle-worn we'd have a serious player on our hands.

Quote from: Aristotle
At what point do Carragher's achievement stop covering for his current performances. We got rid of a 19 year old center back in Daniel Ayala who didn't make half the mistakes Carra has been making in the last 2 seasons. Sentiments and past achievements be damned. Do you honestly, deep down in the very deepest core of your soul, think that a 33 year old Jamie Carragher would start 90% of games for any other team hoping to challenge for trophies around Europe?

Had happened before.

Quote from: Aristotle
I agree with that, up to a certain point and have on many occasions talked about how the squad has lacked a winning mentality. And I have no doubt that being part of a squad that just won the European Cup and had the phenomenal players that it had is easily preferable to coming into squad that has 7 new players and about 15 that left.

But I think that it's more important to the new players to have some sort of future line-up in mind. We're having the new players like Adam, Downing and Henderson adapting to a back 4 that will not be the same next season. Charlie Adam for example would no doubt benefit significantly from starting every chance we get 5-10 yards further up the pitch because the center back brings the ball to him, instead of having to come deep to collect it. I think it's more important now than it was 2-3 seasons ago since we have such a new squad to have some sort of foundations, whether it be Skrtel, Coates or a new center back for that matter. Reina will be in goal, Enrique at left back but what else can we take for granted? An aging Carra, injury prone Agger, inconsistent Skrtel and then Kelly and Johnson who can't stay fit. Which is why I'm advocating putting Coates in who, if nothing else, gives us a height advantage.

In response to someone saying Carra should start ahead of Coates
Quote from: Aristotle
I said that his game was about sliding tackles and back-to-the-wall defending. Which, thanks to Rafa Benitez, made him a starting CB in 2 Champions League Finals. Before that he was a makeshift fullback, holding midfielder and a stop gap for everything that needed. His short comings were glossed over by a phenomenal midfield that consisted amongst others of Mascherano and Sissoko who provided excellent cover for the back 4, whilst Xabi Alonso dropped down and reliefed Carra of the pain of playing the ball.
And it's no secret that some people's opinion of Carragher gets a certain romantic feel due to unforgettable moments like his defending in Istanbul. Again, a phenomenal achievement that no one can or is even trying to take away from him. I'm simply saying that in anyway criticizing Carrgher you get bombarded with endless accounts of Carra's heroic acts in a red shirt, which for whatever reason seem to dwarf the likes of Emlyn Hughes, Phil Neal, Phil Thompson et al who all did wonderful things for the club.

And do please highlight where I said Coates was going to save us from all evil. I simply stated that he has done enough to at least warrant a chance of failing or succeeding.
Do you honestly believe that? So is it a myth that we're losing points, and he's scoring own goals and giving away penalties? So you don't think it's a worrying sign that a man who once upon a time terrorised Shevchenko is now turned by such powerhouse strikers as Jon Walters.

Take for example arguably the best 30+ defender out there, Alessandro Nesta. He was faced one-on-one with Lionel Messi inside his own box and inside 5 seconds he slid in, won the ball, stood up and had passed the ball to the full back when was the last time Carragher did anything close to that. Let alone against someonen in Messi's range of quality. An unfair comparison, I will admit that much as they were two seperate occasions that can not possibly be compared. But to explain my reasoning for doing so. Turn the tables and make it Carra vs. Messi and Nesta vs. Walters and ask a 100 people. Who do you think they'll put money on to come away with the ball?

On the topic of Carragher being a proven winner and that Coates can't handle the PL.
Quote from: Arisotle
I'm pretty sure that people know that there's a difference between the Uruguayan league and the PL. Also I feel confident that if Coates can cope against the likes of Alexis Sanchez he can cope with someone like Peter Crouch. And I mean Chile play high-pressing football, on both a more intense level and with much better players than your average PL side.

On wanting someone other than Carragher is disrespectful and that Benitez and Kenny both picked him and Capello took him to the World Cup.
Quote from: Aristotle
Never said Carra was never a good player, but now he's seriously pushing it. Using England's World Cup squad to back up your arguement won't win many people over as the same squad also had Matthew Upson, Gareth Barry, Joe Cole, Aaron Lennon, Shuan Wright-Phillips, Emile Heskey and Stephen Warnock.

And if Hyypia had signed a new contract, Agger had stayed fit, Rafa gotten more than 1.5m to buy a new center back, San Jose not been shown the door and Skrtel showed more consistency Carra might have been moved on already.

And this will be controversial no doubt, and I'll probably bring on a hailstorm of abuse for it, but does anyone honestly believe that if Carra had been a Liverpool player in the late 70's or the 80's he would have anywhere near 700 appearances for the club?

On the topic of Carragher being too old to play and the sentiments of playing him.
Quote from: Aristotle
I don't know more than the managers, but that doesn't mean I can't question them. You claim with absolute certainty that because they picked him, and are fantastic managers, thusly he is as good as the Maldinis and Baresis of this world. If that works for you, who am I to question it.

33 does not make him an old man. But in terms of great Liverpool defenders it makes him one. Emlyn Hughes, European Cup and League winning captain - 30 when he left LFC. Alan Hansen, possibly our greatest ever CB - 34 when he left Liverpool. Phil Neal's accomplishments don't need to be counted - 34 when he left the club. Tommy Smith - 33 when he played his last game. Phil Thompson - 29 years old when he left. Sami Hyypia - 36 but by then he was used in rotation and despite featuring in important games didn't make 10 games in his last season. Ron Yeats - 34 when he left. Mark Lawrenson - 32 when he left.

All of those were replaced because they had reached that age. All of them are legends at the club with a medal collection envied by all. Do you not think we should be doing the same to Carragher, since we did so to all of them?


I can't quote locked threads so this is the best I could do. But I'd love to have someone tell me that these opinions, made 5 months ago are bandwagon jumping and doing the "popular thing" in "attacking" Carragher. And I said all of this before we saw the true potential of the Skrtel-Agger partnership mind you
My twitter
If Harry can get Spurs to the CL 1/4 final then he could get England to the World Cup final.

Offline sidlfc90

  • Main Stander
  • **
  • Posts: 57
  • Believer!!
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1666 on: March 2, 2012, 05:32:02 PM »
Coates needs more first team football, unfortunatly i cant see him getting that this season with with all our remaining games needing a win and we need the experience at the back now agger is injured. Hope he gets his chance though he does look promising in the games he has played

Offline Vulmea

  • Almost saint-like.....
  • RAWK Scribe
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 4,303
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1667 on: March 2, 2012, 05:32:30 PM »
Paletta signed for Liverpool at 20 years of age, having made 43 appearances for Banfield in the argentine primera divison, the club was believed to have paid a fee of ₤1 Million. When Banfield qualified for the knockout stages of the Copa Libertadores, they altered their 25 man squad for the event to include Paletta and immediately threw him into action against the Colombian team Independiente Medellín. Paletta played well and Banfield progressed, but Paletta was to play no further part in the tournament after being called up to the Argentina Under-20 team to participate in the 2005 FIFA World Youth Championship.

Paletta started in all seven games of the tournament, playing in the heart of the Argentine defence, alongside Lionel Messi and Sergio Agüero. Argentina went on to win the tournament and Paletta's performances attracted the attention of Liverpool.

yep with all of Coates's experience he's a nailed on starter...........

The great enemy of the truth is very often not the lie — deliberate, contrived and dishonest — but the myth — persistent, persuasive and unrealistic.

John F. Kennedy/Shanklyboy.

Offline Aristotle

  • is a bugger for the bottle. Apache tool wielder extraordinaire - especially in wardrobes. The 'Oral B' Specialist.....brushes his cavities vigorously outdoors.
  • RAWK Scribe
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 14,441
  • Happiness depends upon ourselves
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1668 on: March 2, 2012, 05:42:23 PM »
Paletta signed for Liverpool at 20 years of age, having made 43 appearances for Banfield in the argentine primera divison, the club was believed to have paid a fee of ₤1 Million. When Banfield qualified for the knockout stages of the Copa Libertadores, they altered their 25 man squad for the event to include Paletta and immediately threw him into action against the Colombian team Independiente Medellín. Paletta played well and Banfield progressed, but Paletta was to play no further part in the tournament after being called up to the Argentina Under-20 team to participate in the 2005 FIFA World Youth Championship.

Paletta started in all seven games of the tournament, playing in the heart of the Argentine defence, alongside Lionel Messi and Sergio Agüero. Argentina went on to win the tournament and Paletta's performances attracted the attention of Liverpool.

yep with all of Coates's experience he's a nailed on starter...........

Am I being a bit thick here or are you comparing displacing the 06/07 Carragher-Hyypia partnership plus the newly signed Daniel Agger with replacing Carragher today and the Copa America with the FIFA youth championship? ???
My twitter
If Harry can get Spurs to the CL 1/4 final then he could get England to the World Cup final.

Offline Sangria

  • Ally Machoist
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 9,805
  • We all Live in a Red and White Kop
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1669 on: March 2, 2012, 05:44:50 PM »
I'm sorry, but I just don't agree. I think Carragher has made more mistakes this season. Or at very least, has made the same number of mistakes. Coates has had some bad moments, but he's also had some brilliant moments. He's got pace, height, and youth on his side. Carragher's got experience and leadership ability. Both players provide something important.

I think it's close between a legend on his last legs and a young player with a promising CV looking to prove himself.

I know Emlyn Hughes has won the European Cup and is a legend and all, but I like the look of this Alan Hansen kid.
"i just dont think (Lucas is) that type of player that Kenny wants"
Vidocq, 20 January 2011

http://www.redandwhitekop.com/forum/index.php?topic=267148.msg8032258#msg8032258

Offline ArgImAPirate

  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 1,020
  • rat a tat tat
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1670 on: March 2, 2012, 05:50:11 PM »
I know Emlyn Hughes has won the European Cup and is a legend and all, but I like the look of this Alan Hansen kid.

I'm sure that's what my dad would have said if I pulled a Back to the Future and could have hung out with him.

Coates has upside and is potentially the future. If he makes mistakes, we're hoping he'll learn from them. Carragher's a legend and offers a lot, but he's also going to make mistakes. I haven't seen anything that indicates Coates is more prone to mistake than Carragher. I'd argue the other way around, in fact.

It might seem harsh. Or disloyal. But I want the club to be closer to returning to it's glory days. Sometimes that means putting sentiment aside and doing what's best for the team.

Offline Aitken Drum

  • Plays with his ladle
  • Main Stander
  • **
  • Posts: 197
  • Curse you, Walter O'Malley
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1671 on: March 2, 2012, 05:58:34 PM »

Dalglish said: "He's got a fractured rib, so maybe it will be a few weeks.
 

I hope Kenny's right. However, I've had cracked ribs and they took quite a while to heal--6 months. I could barely move for the first three months.   A player on the Boston Red Sox, Jacoby Ellsbury, cracked his ribs in 2010 and was out for the season--April to September.  Agger may be back quick, but often there is muscle damage along with the broken rib. The rib may heal in a month, but the muscle tears take more time.
The race is not always to the swift nor the battle to the strong, but that's the way to bet.--Damon Runyon

Offline Vulmea

  • Almost saint-like.....
  • RAWK Scribe
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 4,303
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1672 on: March 2, 2012, 06:35:38 PM »
Am I being a bit thick here or are you comparing displacing the 06/07 Carragher-Hyypia partnership plus the newly signed Daniel Agger with replacing Carragher today and the Copa America with the FIFA youth championship? ???

apparently you're being deliberately thick

Paletta had potential, he had similar experience to many other quality 20 year olds - he came here too early in his career , he was not ready when he played and his career was badly damaged by throwing him in too early in his career

the views on here have all been suggesting throwing Coates in, he's proven he's up to it, he'll learn from his mistakes - when all the evidence so far has been he isn't ready - he's looked shakey, he was bullied by Oldham,  excuses were made for him when he has played and quite rightly but that does not mean he's ready and it doesn't mean if he plays when he's not ready there's no downside

there are two sides to suggesting playing him thats all I was saying - when comparisons are being made with Jones it seems reasonable to compare Coates with the only other young south american centre half  we've signed
The great enemy of the truth is very often not the lie — deliberate, contrived and dishonest — but the myth — persistent, persuasive and unrealistic.

John F. Kennedy/Shanklyboy.

Offline Wingman

  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 1,917
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1673 on: March 2, 2012, 07:14:18 PM »
I hope Kenny's right. However, I've had cracked ribs and they took quite a while to heal--6 months. I could barely move for the first three months.   

I'll bet you didn't have access to an oxygen chamber and the best medical care money can buy

Offline Al 555

  • Number 1 is Carragher. Number 2 is Carragher. Number 3 is Carragher. Number 4 is Carragher. Likes to play God in his spare time.
  • RAWK Scribe
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 14,523
  • JFT 96
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1674 on: March 2, 2012, 07:24:02 PM »
apparently you're being deliberately thick

Paletta had potential, he had similar experience to many other quality 20 year olds - he came here too early in his career , he was not ready when he played and his career was badly damaged by throwing him in too early in his career

the views on here have all been suggesting throwing Coates in, he's proven he's up to it, he'll learn from his mistakes - when all the evidence so far has been he isn't ready - he's looked shakey, he was bullied by Oldham,  excuses were made for him when he has played and quite rightly but that does not mean he's ready and it doesn't mean if he plays when he's not ready there's no downside

there are two sides to suggesting playing him thats all I was saying - when comparisons are being made with Jones it seems reasonable to compare Coates with the only other young south american centre half  we've signed

Paletta was a punt a small fee for a player for the reserves A player who in a few years might turn out to be a squad player to compare him with Coates a full International with a proven pedigree and someone who slotted straight into the first team squad is ludicrous. As for not being ready how can you be ready to keep a clean sheet against Aguerro, Higuain, Tevez, Messi and Di Maria in the quarters of a major tournament but not be ready to play for your club side.



One thing does need to be said: in the post-Benitez era, there was media-led clamour (but also some politicking going on at the club) to make the club more English; the idea being that the club had lost the very essence of what it means to be ‘Liverpool’. Guillem Ballague 18/11/10

Offline Vulmea

  • Almost saint-like.....
  • RAWK Scribe
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 4,303
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1675 on: March 2, 2012, 07:39:08 PM »
Paletta was a punt a small fee for a player for the reserves A player who in a few years might turn out to be a squad player to compare him with Coates a full International with a proven pedigree and someone who slotted straight into the first team squad is ludicrous. As for not being ready how can you be ready to keep a clean sheet against Aguerro, Higuain, Tevez, Messi and Di Maria in the quarters of a major tournament but not be ready to play for your club side.


a million in football terms in 2005 was worth what in 2011 - 2m, 3m, 4m? its hardly a small punt is it

Coates has very little additional experience - some international caps for Uruguay over a very short space of time - there is no 'proven pedigree' thats just bollocks - he's got one less cap than Gary Cahill and 6 less than Joleon Lescott..........

how can you be ready - to play alongside your countrymen , in a football tournament in south america, when you've played your whole career in south america playing south american style football and not be ready to play in a different continent, in a club game in the most direct and physical league in the world - I dont know you tell me.

I'm not saying he isn't ready or he is, that he wont be a great player or he will be - just that the arguments being made are myopic
 
The great enemy of the truth is very often not the lie — deliberate, contrived and dishonest — but the myth — persistent, persuasive and unrealistic.

John F. Kennedy/Shanklyboy.

Offline Al 555

  • Number 1 is Carragher. Number 2 is Carragher. Number 3 is Carragher. Number 4 is Carragher. Likes to play God in his spare time.
  • RAWK Scribe
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 14,523
  • JFT 96
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1676 on: March 2, 2012, 08:42:19 PM »
a million in football terms in 2005 was worth what in 2011 - 2m, 3m, 4m? its hardly a small punt is it

Coates has very little additional experience - some international caps for Uruguay over a very short space of time - there is no 'proven pedigree' thats just bollocks - he's got one less cap than Gary Cahill and 6 less than Joleon Lescott..........

how can you be ready - to play alongside your countrymen , in a football tournament in south america, when you've played your whole career in south america playing south american style football and not be ready to play in a different continent, in a club game in the most direct and physical league in the world - I dont know you tell me.

I'm not saying he isn't ready or he is, that he wont be a great player or he will be - just that the arguments being made are myopic
 

Myopic when you are talking about the most direct physical League on the eve of a game against Arsenal.

If you are worried about the speed and the
 directness then why are you advocating the return of a slow aerially weak converted full back who has shown time and time again that he simply cannot cope against quick players or big strong players.

As they say the proof is in the pudding Coates has started against Brighton, Stoke home and away, Chelsea and Oldham and we have won four and drew one.

We have the choice between one of the most highly rated young Centre backs on the planet or this seasons Christian Poulson someone who is surviving on reputation alone.
One thing does need to be said: in the post-Benitez era, there was media-led clamour (but also some politicking going on at the club) to make the club more English; the idea being that the club had lost the very essence of what it means to be ‘Liverpool’. Guillem Ballague 18/11/10

Offline Vulmea

  • Almost saint-like.....
  • RAWK Scribe
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 4,303
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1677 on: March 2, 2012, 08:48:47 PM »
Myopic when you are talking about the most direct physical League on the eve of a game against Arsenal.

If you are worried about the speed and the
 directness then why are you advocating the return of a slow aerially weak converted full back who has shown time and time again that he simply cannot cope against quick players or big strong players.

As they say the proof is in the pudding Coates has started against Brighton, Stoke home and away, Chelsea and Oldham and we have won four and drew one.

We have the choice between one of the most highly rated young Centre backs on the planet or this seasons Christian Poulson someone who is surviving on reputation alone.


you really dont have to keep proving my point for me

i'm not advocating anything except Kenny picks the team and we look at it with a bit of balance
The great enemy of the truth is very often not the lie — deliberate, contrived and dishonest — but the myth — persistent, persuasive and unrealistic.

John F. Kennedy/Shanklyboy.

Offline Gnurglan

  • The Swedish Savaloy
  • RAWK Scribe
  • Believer
  • *****
  • Posts: 28,662
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1678 on: March 2, 2012, 08:56:06 PM »
Don't think it matters whether Carra or Coates is the better player right now. We are so eager to bench Maxi and Kuyt, players who contribute, because of their age. We dare to play young players for the future in their place and we like to talk about their bright future. If they don't perform, we have no real problems with that because they are for the future.

CB? Here we have a choice to go with the oldest player in the squad, or a young player who has proven himself in a big international tournament. If we apply the same logic as we do in midfield, Coates should almost be a guaranteed first pick. Not saying we should play Coates in every game when Agger is out, but we should play him at least as much as we play Carra.

          * * * * *


"The key isn't the system itself, but how the players adapt on the pitch. It doesn't matter if it's 4-3-3 or 4-4-2, it's the role of the players that counts." Rafa Benitez

Offline JamesLS7

  • Kopite
  • ****
  • Posts: 574
  • Rafa Is My Hero.
Re: Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel Partnership
« Reply #1679 on: March 2, 2012, 09:22:31 PM »
I'd say Coates is better than Carra as a player now.

The man was young player of the tournament at the Copa America.
When discussing Dirk Kuyt's work rate :

I don't think he works as hard as some people claim. No harder, for example, than Stewart Downing.

18 League Titles and 5 European Cups. Get counting.