You make a very good point about the love for individual players within the fanbase.
It's not so much the love for individual players, cultish or otherwise, because that's a completely natural thing for supporters, as always. It's more the overreliance on individuals for drive and motivation. The sense of quickly speading demoralisation if your star misses a game or two for example, or the constant drama surrounding a single player throughout an entire season (Suarez, Gerrard, Torres, etc.). But that idiosyncratic quality still counts for something in this side, it just isn't a ticket to ride along languidly as though you own the place.
Funnily enough, it took a highly individual cult hero, Klopp himself, to gee us up enough to nab those 3 points!